Review by Booklist Review
This striking picture-book debut by a graphic artist requires repeat readings to fully appreciate its ambitious visualization of music and its metropolitan scope. The story is straightforward: a young girl on the way to a free concert becomes separated from her grown-up in the subway station. Although she never reaches the concert, she discovers a city full of music, from buskers to musicians practicing in their homes. Martin uses repeated patterns (a flock of yellow birds, rigid skyscrapers), primary colors, and fantastical images (fish flying over the streets, giant ballerinas dancing on rooftops) to convey the emotion that music stirs within the girl. Her journey is one of wonder, delight, and a little introspection, and ends not with music but with provocative silence back home. The text is clearly secondary to the illustrations. Printed in a small point size, the words are often difficult to read and sometimes absorbed by the background images. But children drawn into the arresting pictures won't miss the words, or the message: Music is everywhere. --Dean, Kara Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
A girl loses hold of her father's hand in a subway station and finds herself alone in the middle of a city. In Martin's hands, this potentially scary theme becomes a hymn to beauty. The city is filled with music: pianos sound, drums beat, and a band plays ("there is music around every corner/ it comes from the street/ and fills the sky"). The girl wanders, listening and observing ("it starts as a sprout/ and bursts into a forest"), watching and dancing ("it leaps and spins/ across the rooftops") until she finds her way safely home. Martin, in her children's book debut, delivers images of meditative calm; in each spread, blocks of translucent color fill in the background, leaving the contours of the pictures' subjects-hands playing instruments, bodies, buildings-outlined by the white space that remains. Martin succeeds in capturing a world of sound using only visual cues; lyrical yet militantly unsentimental, the book's cool appearance is reinforced by the face of the girl, whose lean features could be an adult's. Comes in a foldout dust jacket on which Martin's artwork is reproduced. All ages. (July) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 5-8-Beset with boredom, the needle of her record player broken, a young teen rushes off with a family member to a free concert. On the crowded subway, she gets separated and consoles herself: "I can find my own way.if I follow the sound." And she does. She finds music everywhere and overcomes her fear of navigating the city solo. The story is told visually through the gradual outpouring of color; the division of space in surprising vertical and horizontal lines, with cityscape backgrounds like blueprints; and colors layered as if silk-screened. Newsprint gray overwhelmingly marks the beginning of the girl's journey, but the scene gradually brightens with her yellow raincoat and yellow birds, a series of street musicians' red instruments, and the blue, slanting rain. The economical text is a paean to music: "It starts as a sprout and bursts into a forest.even the moon wants to listen." Visual symbols that celebrate childhood and discovery abound, like red shoes and a kite in the form of a carp. To the music of a guitar duo, the girl dances amid orbs of color and starlight before finding her way home and into joyfully relieved arms. Craftsmanship reigns in this title. A flock of birds embossed in gold flies from the back to the front of the textured orange binding, and the jacket folds out into a two-sided poster. A perfect book for music lovers and bibliophiles.-Sara Lissa Paulson, American Sign Language and English Lower School PS 347, New York City (c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
On her way to a concert, a young girl loses the hand of the adult taking her. Following a trail of music through the city, she finds her way home where "the best songs love you back."This familiar home-away-home narrative arc is set in a busy city. Coming out from the subway, the girl hears music everywhere, beginning with a flute player whose notes emerge embodied as yellow birds. Music is on street corners, floating through windows and in the natural world. Kites carry her to the rooftops, where she dances with ballerinas. Double-page spreads feature clean, stylized shapes. Gray at first, these illustrations gradually fill with color. The yellow of the child's slicker matches the birds she follows; though small, she's easy to find. Cats are everywhere. The minimal text is set in a small font, often part of the negative space on the page. This is clearly designed for sharing, not for independent reading. Adults will need to interpret the image of an empty turntable that opens the story and to provide reassurance on the scary pages where the two hands separate and the girl is lost among the faceless crowd.This lovely tribute to the power of music to take us away and soothe our fears will likely fly over the heads of its intended audience.(Picture book. 4-7)]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
