Review by New York Times Review
MAILE MELOY, author of two novels and two story collections that have been praised for their meticulous realism, has written her first book for young readers, and defying expectations of admirers such as myself, it's a fantasy. Though a longtime fan of Meloy, I couldn't help approaching "The Apothecary," a story of teenage spies and transformative elixirs, with trepidation. So it was a happy surprise that the book, with its intricately constructed plot, well-paced suspense, credibly rendered fantastical elements, thoughtfully drawn characters and authentically detailed settings, satisfies on all levels. Even for a reader predisposed against the genre. The opening chapters are reassuringly Meloy: 14-year-old Janie Scott describes her life in 1950s Hollywood with her parents, a radio-television writing team, "the smartest, funniest parents I knew." Childhood in postwar California is blissful - eating oranges off sweet-smelling trees in the front yard, playing in the ocean waves - even if punctuated by atomic bomb drills at school and shadowed by a new war in faraway Korea. But when Janie is followed home by a black sedan, the hitherto unrecognized threat of McCarthyism and blacklisting changes her life. Fleeing an upcoming court appearance, her parents whisk her, grumpy and protesting, to London, where they have been promised wprk on a new television series. "It'll be like living in a Jane Austen novel," her mother enthuses. "You mean I'll get married in the end?" Janie shoots back. "I'm 14." Once in London, the Scotts are taken aback by the city's grimness, which Meloy depicts with satisfying realism. They are depressed by the damp, dust and cold, and disoriented by the constraints of shopping with ration cards, and without niceties like chocolate. Janie faces the agony of being new in a school where students are addressed as Miss and Mister; uniforms are mandatory; and the requisite beautiful, wealthy snob, Sarah Pennington pronounces Janie's home "California" ("as if perhaps I had made it up," Janie thinks). FOR readers, the biggest suspense is whether romance will blossom with Janie's sandy-haired fellow student Benjamin Burrows, whose "thrilling, defiant voice" and refusal to hide under the desks during the bomb drill make her "heart beat inside my rib cage at such an unexpected pace." But more than romance with Benjamin awaits Janie. The boy, who aspires to the Secret Intelligence Service, and his father, a gentle local apothecary, propel her. into dizzyingly improbable experiences that build in complexity and urgency. First, the apothecary is kidnapped, shortly after hurriedly entrusting Benjamin and Janie with his Pharmacopoeia, an aged volume of alchemy with recipes for medicines and methods of healing, which, to Janie, looks "like a very old, important version of my mother's overstuffed 'Joy of Cooking.'" The teenagers are then accompanied by a cunning young pickpocket, fittingly named Pip, and endure harrowing, often life-threatening escapades, only to discover that Benjamin's father is part of a small international group of scientists fighting to suppress atomic bomb testing and counteract the destructive effects of radiation. Benjamin and Janie join the band's dangerous mission to the Arctic to stop an impending Russian test masterminded by a young physicist named Andrei Sakharov. Meloy begins with the usual elements of good middle-grade fiction: a character removed from her ordinary life, the temporary disappearance of one or more parents, a tentative first romance. Slowly and carefully, she turns the story into a spy-filled mystery, and then crosses over into full-fledged fantasy, in which the effects of chemistry and physics push past accepted limits. The impossible first occurs during a rooftop chase scene worthy of any thriller as the desperate threesome escape their pursuers by drinking an avian elixir and turning into birds, each true to his or her size and nature. Equally enthralling, though, and every bit as magical, is Janie's first kiss, many chapters and adventures later: "His lips were warm and soft against mine, and the night air was cold. Shivers went down my spine from the place where his fingers were tangled in my hair and pressing against my skin." Meloy weaves fantasy into a fine work of historical fiction, bringing to life the cold-war era when everyday life was permeated by fear of nuclear disaster and Russian spies lurking everywhere. More important, though, she brings to her first book for young readers the same emotional resonance that has won acclaim for her adult fiction, grounding her story in the intricacies of family love, friendship and loyalty, blended here with the complicated fluctuations of adolescence. Krystyna Poray Goddu is the author of "Dollmakers and Their Stories: Women Who Changed the World of Play."
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [October 16, 2011]
Review by Booklist Review
Janie, 14, has been living happily with her screenwriter parents in Hollywood. But it's 1952, and blacklisting makes it imperative that the family moves to London, where a TV job awaits. Janie is not happy about this, but a startling adventure opens to her as she becomes friends with Benjamin Burrows, whose father is an apothecary, and not just any apothecary. Mr. Burrows is part of a small, international group of scientists who are trying to contain the destructive results of the atomic bomb, including a weapon that is being tested off the coast of Russia. Those who know little about blacklisting, the Cold War, and European life after WWII will just have to dive into the fantasy-adventure pool, which runs long and deep. Magic elixirs, transformational disguises, and everyday cunning help Janie, Benjamin, and several scientists elude capture and defeat the desperate cabal that supports the Soviet Union. Readers must be willing to traverse a complicated tale and avoid stepping in a few plot holes, but Meloy offers a strong narrator in Janie and an intriguing mix of history and mystery.--Cooper, Ilen. Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
When the House Committee on Un-American Activities targets Janie's television writer parents, the 14-year-old and her family flee from Los Angeles to London. There, Janie meets Benjamin, a "defiant" classmate, and his father, the neighborhood apothecary, who is involved in much more than hot water bottles and aspirin. In fact, he is part of a long line of apothecaries who have discovered miraculous secrets-truth serums, invisibility, amazing physical transformations-and he is now working with scientists on an incredible plan that has global ramifications with regard to the escalating tensions between the Soviet Union and the United States. Some readers may need to brush up on cold war history to fully appreciate the stakes, but even those with a vague understanding of the times will be quickly swept up in this thoroughly enjoyable adventure, filled with magic, humor, memorable characters, and just a bit of sweet romance. With evocative, confident prose and equally atmospheric spot art from Schoenherr, adult author Meloy's first book for young readers is an auspicious one. Readers will hope they haven't heard the last from Janie and Benjamin. Ages 10-up. (Oct.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 5-8-A fairly interesting mystery set mostly in 1952 London, The Apothecary offers a little of everything; magic, romance, mystery, and historical fiction. When friends of Janie's parents are blacklisted in Hollywood (they are a television writing team), the Scotts move to London. Around the corner from their flat is a mysterious shop with an enigmatic apothecary. The man's son is Janie's new friend at school. When she and Benjamin, who aspires to be a spy, happen to witness a handoff involving a Russian attache in the park, the teens get more than they bargained for. As it turns out, not only is Benjamin's father involved, but the Latin instructor at their school is also a part of this web of espionage. The two rush to save the apothecary only to find out that he is attempting to stop a nuclear test in Soviet territory. Everyone goes along to help stop the explosion. However, the magic occasionally feels like a contrivance to move the plot forward instead of an organic part of the fantasy. The ending is sort of a free-for-all, and the created world doesn't really keep to the rules set up at the beginning. Nonetheless, this is a highly readable adventure/mystery, and it is greatly enhanced by Schoenherr's graceful and evocative illustrations.-Robin Henry, Wakeland High School, Frisco, TX (c) Copyright 2011. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Following the paths of Neil Gaiman, Julia Alvarez and Carl Hiaasen, bestselling author Meloy (Both Ways Is the Only Way I Want It, 2009, etc.) takes a successful plunge into middle-grade fiction.Before the House Committee on Un-American Activities can interrogate Janie Scott's Hollywood writing-team parents for being possible Communists, they move to London. "I was no witty, patient, adaptable Jane Austen," the 14-year-old admits as she recalls helping to save the world in 1952. While palling around with Benjamin Burrows, who'd rather be a spy than follow in the apothecary family tradition, Janie becomes entangled with Cold War espionage after Benjamin's father mysteriously disappears, leaving behind a secret 700-year-old book of magic elixirs. As the teens, joined by pickpocket Pip (seemingly plucked out of Great Expectations), search for the apothecary (truly an alchemist), they must also outrun their dreamy Latin teacher (who could be a double agent), rescue a kidnapped Chinese chemist and work with other scientists from around the world to thwart the Soviet's detonation of an atomic bomb 20 times more powerful than Hiroshima's, all while testing out some of the elixirs along the way.Although Janie's narration loses some of its charm and humor as the adventure escalates, its blend of history, culture and the anxiety of the time with magical "science" will keep readers just as spellbound as the characters. (art not seen) (Historical fantasy. 10-14)]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.