Review by Booklist Review
Adventurers, take up ye swords! Several of the battle scenes in this massive conclusion to Paolini's Inheritance Cycle and, wow, are there a lot of them are so invigorating that even with all the fountaining of blood and clashing of steel, readers young and old will be begging to enlist. Let's start with the good because, largely, this novel is a rousing success: Paolini fulfills nearly every promise set forward in Eragon (2003), with the young Rider fulfilling his destiny; Roran becoming a warrior of legend; Murtagh facing up to his lineage; and Galbatorix finally taking center stage for the final act, where his evil plans begin to make a disturbing amount of sense. Paolini is especially apt at depiciting the queasy nature of unnatural alliances, and each of the 78 chapters contains a meaty or enjoyable nugget, even if it's one of Paolini's trademark tangents (the step-by-step construction of a dwarf's thardsvergundnzmal, for instance). Still, the novel isn't perfect: many characters are so burdened by Tolkeinesque posturing that they are more fascinatingly mythic than truly fleshed out, and the long-winded proceedings follow a fairly predictable, The Return of the King-like arc. But this is every bit as challenging and ornate as its predecessors, and very few of the millions of fans will be disappointed. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: How does a 2.5-million-copy first printing sound? An 18-city tour, TV advertising, and dedicated apps ensure that this global publishing event will be just that: an event.--Kraus, Daniel Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Almost 10 years after Paolini self-published Eragon in 2002, he concludes the epic saga of the Inheritance Cycle with this thick fourth volume, the longest yet in the series. With Eragon, his dragon Saphira, and their many allies poised to do final battle against the evil emperor Galbatorix, there is still plenty of unfinished business to wrap up. Cities need to be liberated, enemy leaders (including Eragon's half-brother Murtagh) must be dealt with, prophecies await fulfillment, and a few game-changing secrets will be revealed. In full Tolkienesque style, Paolini luxuriates in excess details, side quests, and a lengthy denouement in which every last thread is wrapped up. The solidly entertaining plot is fleshed out with defining moments for every major character and a sense of completion (temporary or permanent) for all involved. While this final chapter is bogged down by an almost obsessive complexity with regard to the world-building, Paolini leaves readers with the satisfaction of a journey's end, along with the promise of new beginnings. It's a can't-miss for fans and completionists, and a worthy end to the story. Ages 12-up. (Nov.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
(Heroic fantasy. 12-15)]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.