Review by Choice Review
Written by a psychologist (Schwartz) and a political scientist (Sharpe), this book will be invaluable in a multitude of fields. Indeed, everyone could benefit from reading it, because Schwartz and Sharpe (both, Swarthmore College) deal with how institutional cultures affect individuals' everyday lives. The authors begin by pointing to the distrust many Americans now feel toward their institutions and contend that the usual devising of new rules and incentives is not sufficient for real reform. They cite numerous examples from the fields of business, education, medicine, law, government, and the military, for example, the rigid standardization of educational curricula and mandatory judicial sentencing prior to a 2005 Supreme Court ruling. Such measures reflect a distrust of the judgment of teachers and judges and hinder their development of practical wisdom, as Aristotle understood it. Schwartz and Sharpe maintain that this practical wisdom is the critical present need in the US and that it will improve both institutions' and individuals' own well-being. Such wisdom combines proper aims with proper skills and is best developed by trial-and-error experience and good feedback and mentoring. Clearly written and including endnotes, this book is a must read in the fields mentioned above as well as in psychology. Summing Up: Essential. All readers. W. G. Moss emeritus, Eastern Michigan University
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review
In this thoughtful consideration of an Aristotelian ideal, Schwartz and Sharpe delve deeply into what it means to practice wisdom. What makes this an engrossing (and socially significant) read is not the nod to the ancient Greeks but, rather, the numerous examples of people in all facets of American life who seek wisdom in their professional and personal choices. The authors consider how mandatory sentencing has removed the element of judgment from a judge's position, citing a heartbreaking example. As they further make the case for empathy and patience, they delve into health care, education, and the groundbreaking work being conducted in the extraordinarily successful Veterans Court in Buffalo. Repeatedly, by example, they stress the necessity of a human approach, without politics, to the issues of how we live and interact with each other. And through all of this, Schwartz and Sharpe demonstrate how relevant Aristotle is today. As surprising as it is convincing, this thoughtful work will long stay with readers, as will the many people who are profiled on its pages.--Mondor, Colleen Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Schwartz (The Paradox of Choice) and Sharpe, both professors at Swarthmore College, explore our increasing distrust of and disenchantment with our institutions-governmental, medical, legal-an alienation shared by professionals such as doctors, lawyers, and teachers and the populations they serve. The authors exhort a revival of what Aristotle referred to as "practical wisdom"-figuring out the right way to do the right thing at the right time-not merely following established rules. Particular circumstances call for specific responses-the key is a flexibility impossible in ossified bureaucracies. Schwartz and Sharpe focus on finding a balance between professional commitment and financial profitability, praising "canny outlaws" who find ways to exercise practical wisdom, from judges to hospital custodians attentive to context. This highly recommended and important book offers an antidote to the mistrust that plagues the morale both in the workplace and beyond. (Jan.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Swarthmore professors Schwartz (Social Theory; The Paradox of Choice: Why More is Less, 2004, etc.) and Sharpe (Political Science; co-author: Drug War Politics, 1996, etc.) take note of the paucity of applied sagacity and offer advice on how to retrieve it for a better social order.The book is a self-help title, but more in-depth and nuanced than most. The authors cite Rousseau, Wittgenstein and other philosophers, as well as Malcolm Gladwell and George Bailey, the hero of It's a Wonderful Life. Most frequently referenced, however, is Aristotle, who sought "phronesis," which, we are told, is simply "practical wisdom." The authors support their common-sense prescriptions with lengthy anecdotes of applied intelligence by physicians, teachers, lawyers and health-care workers. They also advise practitioners in professions like medicine, jurisprudence, education and finance on the proper uses of judgment, ethics, empathy and detachment. The guidance is based on research in the social sciences and psychology, with a few comments touching on epistemology. Schwartz and Sharpe counsel on the role of the "canny outlaw" who, like Robin Hood, disdains the rules for the greater good. Don't rely on incentives alone, they say, and be happy in your workin support, they present parables of those who are happy in theirs. Inevitably, there is more than a whiff of pedantry here; pertinent material and apt points tend to get lost in illustrative verbiage and extraneous matter. The conclusion, it seems, is that practical wisdom tells us to eschew greed, be slow to anger, be considerate, be good and think. In short, it's a call for decency and good behavior.An earnest, didactic manual on doing the right thing, a topic that remains tricky to teach.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
