The fever How malaria has ruled humankind for 500,000 years

Sonia Shah

Book - 2010

Saved in:

2nd Floor Show me where

614.532/Shah
1 / 1 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
2nd Floor 614.532/Shah Checked In
Subjects
Published
New York : Sarah Crichton Books/Farrar, Straus, and Giroux 2010.
Language
English
Main Author
Sonia Shah (-)
Edition
First edition
Physical Description
307 pages ; 24 cm
Bibliography
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN
9780374230012
  • 1. Malaria at our Doorstep
  • 2. Birth of a Killer
  • 3. Swept in Malaria's Current
  • 4. Malarial Ecologies
  • 5. Pharmacological Failure
  • 6. The Karma of Malaria
  • 7. Scientific Solutions
  • 8. The Disappeared: How Malaria Vanished from the West
  • 9. The Spray-Gun War
  • 10. The Secret in the Mosquito
  • Notes
  • Acknowledgments
  • Index
Review by Choice Review

Throughout most of medical history, fever was considered a disease. Well before it was identified as a symptom and before its many causes were identified, one form of febrile illness was distinctive enough to be separated from the others and termed "malaria," based on its early association with the "bad air" of warm and swampy regions. Even though the parasite causing malaria was identified and its transmission by mosquitoes determined in the 19th century, the disease still eludes eradication and remains rampant in some regions. Investigative journalist Shah relates the story of malaria in this well-researched book with 50 pages of annotations for 250 pages of text. She offers a dramatic recounting, opening with the personal notes of an American of Indian descent whose family experienced the disease, and interspersing her experiences and reactions as she visits areas where the disease still prevails. This volume captures the early history of malaria, with a focus on failed attempts to eradicate it, given the evolutionarily adaptive features of the parasite and the mosquito, as well as the geopolitical and economic conditions in the regions where the disease lingers. Summing Up: Recommended. General readers. G. Eknoyan Baylor College of Medicine

Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review

Investigative journalist Shah maintains her signature pattern (Crude, 2004; The Body Hunters, 2006) here, exposing both the seemly and not-so-seemly aspects of the subject under review. As Shah demonstrates, when it comes to taming, never mind eradicating, malaria, the disease is cannily able to keep the ball in humankind's court. Notwithstanding, people in tropical climes who live with its ubiquitous presence have over time come to uneasy terms with the fever. That is not to say they would not benefit from a cure. Indeed, their need is most critical. It's just that when Western nontropical humans are exposed to malaria, they suffer its worst effects, then tackle the problem in largely ineffectual ways. And it is not for want of money (think Bill and Melinda Gates). But Shah takes no prisoners, blasting everyone, including the World Health Organization. Even Harvard's state-of-the art Malaria Initiative takes it on the chin for eschewing unglamorous but effectual grunt work in favor of lavishly funded . . . economy building technology. Malaria may rule humankind, but Shah rules the in-depth investigative report.--Chavez, Donna Copyright 2010 Booklist

From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

This fascinating, mordant pop-sci account tells us why malaria is one of the world's greatest scourges, killing a million people every year and debilitating another 300 million, and why we have remained complacent about it. Journalist Shah (The Body Hunters: Testing New Drugs in the World's Poorest Patients) shows how the Plasmodium parasite, entering through a mosquito's bite and feasting on human red blood cells, has altered human history by destroying armies, undermining empires, and driving changes in our very genome. We've learned to fight back with antimalarial drugs and insecticides, but malaria's adaptability and its buzzing vector, Shah notes, give it the upper hand. Shah provides an intricate and lucid rundown of the biology and ecology of malaria, but her most original insights concern the ways in which human society accommodates and abets the parasite. (The impoverished denizens of Africa's malaria belt, she observes, would sometimes rather use the pesticide-laced bed nets sent by Western aid groups to catch fish.) Shah's is an absorbing account of human ingenuity and progress, and of their heartbreaking limitations. 16 pages of b&w illus. (July) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review

Investigative journalist Shah (The Body Hunters: How the Drug Industry Tests Its Products on the World's Poorest Patients, 2006, etc.) argues that the mosquito-borne parasite is in control and will remain so.The author opens with a chapter describing recent outbreaks of malaria in relatively untouched areas, then digs deep into the past to chronicle the role Plasmodium falciparumthe most virulent malarial speciesand its kin have played in human history. Warm temperatures and standing water create breeding grounds for the female Anopheles mosquito, the species able to house the parasite's sexual forms, which are transmitted in saliva when she bites a human or animal host. Environmental and ecological factors are critical in malaria outbreaks. Shah explains how such factors, natural and manmade, have accounted for the rise and fall of empires, battles won or lost, the success or failure of human settlements. The disease only became more devastating following the Industrial Revolution, which brought deforestation and the damming of rivers to create millponds and reservoirs. As the tropics were conquered by Western powers, malaria's devastation was inflicted unequally in colonies where white occupiers lived on high ground with proper drainage, areas off-limits to the natives below. While quinine was long recognized as malaria therapy, the cause of the disease was not established until the turn of the 20th centurythat story by itself makes a fascinating chapter in medical history. Over time, other drugs appeared, as well as insecticides like DDT, once touted as the sure eradicator of malaria...until it wasn't. Shah's point is that global-health policymakers, including the Gates Foundation, continue to look for magic bullets to prevent or cure the disease. But there aren't any. Bed nets and combined therapies are useful, but until the focus is shifted to building native capacity and good governancein education, schools, roads and clinicsmalaria will continue to devastate millions.A sad, sobering account with important lessons for medical historians, anthropologists, biologists and, most of all, policymakers.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

The view through the mosquito net is blurry, but I can see the thick skin of grime on the leading edge of each blade of the ceiling fan as it slowly whirs around, keening alarmingly. This is how it was every summer when I visited my grandmother's house in southern India. While my cousins snore on the bed mats laid across the floor beside me, glistening bodies bathed in the warm night breeze, my sleeping mat is ensconced in a hot, gauzy cage. The mosquitoes descend from the darkened corners of the whitewashed room and perch menacingly on the taut netting, ready to exploit any fl icker of movement from their prey within. It is hard to fall asleep knowing they are there, watching me, but eventually I drop off and my tensed body uncurls. They sneak into the gaps my protruding limbs create, and feast. In the morning, all my hard work of trying to fi t in, to overcome the Americanness of my suburban New England life, has been undone, for my Indian cousins are smooth and brown while I am speckled with bleeding scabs. My grandmother vigorously pats talcum powder over my wounds, the white powder caking pink with congealed blood, as my cousins snicker. I don't understand how they escape unscathed while I am tormented. But incomprehension is part of the package of these childhood summers in India. Just outside my grandmother's house ragged families huddle in rubble along the road and use the train tracks as their toilet. They wave their sticklike arms in my face and moan woefully when we pass by on the way to temple, caricatures of beggars. One boy's leg has swollen to the size of a log, and is gray and pimpled, from some disease brought on by a mosquito bite. My grandmother tightens her grip on my hand. We give the children nothing. I can't understand this, either. When we get to the white marble temple, it is full of incense and golden statues encrusted with diamonds and rubies--to my seven-year-old mind, the very picture of prosperity. Part of me despises my estrangement, my incomprehension, the fact that I must sleep under the suffocating net and take the malaria pills while my cousins don't. But part of me is secretly glad. The boy with the swollen leg frightens me. The family who lives on the curb frightens me. India frightens me. These fears, for the girl who is supposed to be Indian but isn't, are unspeakable. When no one is looking, I crush the mosquitoes' poised little figures with my palm and smear the remains on a hidden seam in the couch. Our Jain religion forbids violence of any kind. No eating meat. No swatting flies. My grandmother wears a mask over her mouth while she prays, to protect airborne microbes from inadvertent annihilation in her inhalations, and considers walking on blades of grass a sin. Meanwhile, there I am in the corner, cravenly pulverizing mosquito corpses behind my back, blood literally on my hands. Back home in New England, the mosquitoes still bite, but there are no nets at night, no pills to take, no scary beggars on the side of the road. We shop for forgettable plastic trinkets at the mall. My fear and loathing of the mosquito are blunted into games of tag. My father calls himself Giant Mosquito, undulates his fingers like proboscises and chases me and my sister. It's scary, but fun-scary. We screech with glee and stampede through the house. • • • Thirty years later, on the S-shaped land bridge between the North and South American continents, I meet José Calzada. Calzada is a mosquito stalker of sorts, and I, the mosquito hater, have come to learn about the local mosquitoes and their exploits. A parasitologist from Panama City, Panama, Calzada spends his time rushing to the scene of disease outbreaks across the isthmus. The mosquito-borne parasite that causes malaria, Plasmodium, is one of his specialties. It is April 2006. For most of the past century, there hasn't been much work in this fi eld for people such as Calzada. Panama prides itself on being one of just a handful of tropical developing countries to have tamed its mosquitoes and nearly conquered malaria. American military engineers built a canal through Panama in the early 1900s, and forced malaria to retreat to the remote fringes of the country. Since then it has stagnated, primarily in its most benign incarnation, vivax malaria, which is rarely fatal. But things have changed in recent years, and Calzada has agreed to show me some obscure signs. He emerges from the imposing Gorgas Memorial Institute, Panama's sole health research center. Clean-shaven and trim, Calzada has a slightly worried look in his eyes that is off set by high cheekbones suggesting a perpetual halfsmile. I wait while he meticulously changes out of his work clothes-- button-down oxford shirt and slacks--and into a T-shirt and jeans. Climbing into my diminutive white rental car and tossing a baseball cap on top of his backpack in the backseat, he patiently directs me out of the labyrinthine metropolis. Navigating Panama City's congested streets, past shiny skyscrapers and packed cafés, is a task that challenges even my well-honed Boston driv ing skills. After twenty minutes heading east out of the city, the road turns quiet. It's a lovely drive, with hills in the distance, verdant pasture and scrub unbroken save for a few elaborately gated houses set far back from the road. Colombian drug lords, Calzada says, by way of explanation. Another hour passes, and the road rises, a glittering lake coming into view, just visible through a tangle of jungle. As we near the water, the pavement ends, and we pull over. Here, at the end of the road, is the town of Chepo. From what I can see, it consists of a wooden lean-to facing a sleepy roadside café. Two police officers amble out of the lean-to, which turns out to be a checkpoint. They take my passport and vanish, leaving Calzada and me to buy a cold drink at the near-empty café. As we sit, I can just make them out in the murk within the lean-to, inspecting the blue passport with great care, turning it over and over in their hands as if for clues to some baffling mystery. Inspection completed, Calzada leads us on foot behind the road. Th e hillside is green and lush, with a slick red clay track leading to the crest. He heads up and I follow gingerly. At the top of the hill lies an improb able settlement. Packed together, not ten feet apart, are dozens of hand-built ranchos, their thatched roofs sitting on top of roughly hewn wooden poles. More arbor than hut, some of the structures rest on concrete slabs, with airy wooden-slat walls on three sides, but most are fully open-air, situated directly on the packed dirt. Inside the ranchos, smoldering fi res are encircled by battered metal cooking vats, parrots sit on overturned baskets, and hammocks sway from high rafters. From the road, Chepo seems abandoned, but in fact, three hundred of Panama's indigenous Kuna people live here, tucked away. It starts to rain, and we duck under the eaves of a rancho. Women pass to and fro in bright puff ed-sleeve cotton blouses with patterned molas tied around their waists and elaborate beaded anklets that reach up to their calves. They are cutting plantains, carrying plump naked children. One puts out a giant metal vat to collect the rainwater sliding off the thatch. A rooster strides by purposefully. A half-dozen boys clad in saggy cotton underwear and wearing shell necklaces happily kick a defl ated green soccer ball. One boy, around eight years old and wearing cracked red plastic flip-flops, gnaws on a green mango pit while absentmindedly pulling on his penis. A little girl walks by holding a baby covered in a rash, whom she hands to me easily. It is a tranquil scene, earthy and ripe, this hidden place at the end of the road. It is soon apparent that most of the residents are in one of the larger ranchos, sitting around a smoky fire. Peeking in, we see them singing softly and dancing. A few are sprawled on the clay floor, facedown, passed out. We've arrived in the midst of a fiesta, Calzada whispers to me. A local girl has recently menstruated for the fi rst time, and so the community has spent the day drinking chicha fuerte, a brew made from fermented corn. As we watch, a woman and a boy lift a comatose mud-caked man off the ground and drag him home. Two women from inside the rancho follow them to the doorway, smiling. Aside from a few furtive looks, they ignore us almost entirely. It wasn't like this the year before, when Calzada first came here. There is no En glish-language record of what happened to Chepo's Kuna community in 2005, save the one you are reading now. The mosquitoes that hatched from Chepo's stagnant puddles, the edges of the lake below, in the open-water cisterns, had gone on a rampage. Contaminated with the most malevolent malaria parasites known to humankind in their spittle, they alit on the exposed and unclad Kuna around them. By the time Calzada and his team arrived, nearly half of the settlement was fevered, terrified, immobilized in their hammocks. After days of triage, Calzada brought samples of the Kuna's infected blood back to his lab at the Gorgas Institute to analyze. The most common malaria in this part of Panama is the relatively benign vivax strain, caused by malarial parasites called Plasmodium vivax. Instead, Calzada identifi ed parasites called Plasmodium falciparum, which are more commonly found in sub-Saharan Africa. Worse, this was no regular strain of P. falciparum, but a particularly nasty one that had evolved re sis tance to standard antimalarial drugs, a trick the parasites may have picked up somewhere in Southeast Asia. Malaria experts around the world had been tracking the spread of this bug for years. At Chepo, Calzada had discovered its northernmost beachhead. There was precious little evidence, when we first arrived in Chepo, of the village's connection to modern industrial life. In one rancho, I saw a battery-powered radio, but other than that, we might have been in the preindustrial world: there were no toilets, no running water, no electricity. But then, as the rain steadily turned the dirt lanes between the ranchos into mud, impromptu streams formed, ferrying Chepo's hidden debris to the lake: a blue plastic sandal, a crushed orange juice container, a small gas can, and a shopping bag came bobbing down the hill. We were, after all, less than two hours' drive from a boisterous city of three million, a center of international commerce through which passes 5 percent of the world's trade. The scene of malaria's malevolent homecoming in this secluded settlement cast its shadow over the very doorstep of the global economy. The 2005 epidemic at Chepo did not occur in a vacuum. On the contrary, between 1998 and 2004, malaria cases in Panama quadrupled. 2 And globally, malaria's death toll has grown inexorably since 1981. In 1995, Europe suff ered ninety thousand cases of malaria. Then, in 1996, military troops in war-torn Afghanistan sparked a malaria epidemic across Central Asia. Soon, Azerbaijan, Tajikistan, and Turkey suff ered malaria outbreaks. By 2003, Plasmodium had preyed on ten times more people in Central Asia than just a decade before,5 and a tsunami of people carrying the parasite from Africa and Asia began showing up in Europe. Today, eight times more malaria patients arrive at clinics and hospitals across Europe than did in the 1970s, and back then, most of the Plasmodium imported into Europe was of the vivax strain. Now, nearly 70 percent is the deadly P. falciparum. These days, mosquitoes infect between 250 million and 500 million people with malaria every year, and close to 1 million perish. Equally shocking is the sheer length of malaria's tenure upon us. Humans have suffered the disease for more than 500,000 years. And not only does it still plague us, but it has also become even more lethal. Th at's quite a feat for a disease we've known how to prevent and cure for more than a hundred years. During that same time, we've vanquished any number of similarly once-commanding pathogens, from smallpox to the plague, and have come to expect nearly complete control over newer pathogens, such as SARS or avian fl u. Th e few that slip through our fingers, such as HIV, are the rightful subjects of anguish and soul-searching. Yet despite the fact that we've known about malaria since ancient times, and have the drugs, kill ing chemicals, and know-how to avoid it, something about this disease still short-circuits our weaponry. After dropping Calzada off, I headed back to my rental cottage along the banks of the canal, where I spent the evening reviewing my notes. Th e cottage was on stilts, and cooled by ceiling fans, but the window screens were old and sagging, bent and giving way from the window frame. Every morning in Panama I would awaken with some unexpected swelling from the mosquitoes' nighttime blood feasts: under my eye, on my eyelid, on the palm of my hand. Smashed mosquitoes, glued to the surface with their own internal juices, dotted the walls. A flimsy mosquito landed gently on my forearm. A familiar spike of rage rose as I watched, incredulous, as the insect prepared to puncture my skin with her proboscis. How dare she! Instinctively, my hand snapped up. Somewhere inside that cold-blooded, brittle body lurked entities whose exertions explained the making of rich and poor, sick and healthful. My hand came down a bit slower for the passing thought, and I brushed the mosquito away like a crumb. Her delicate legs snarled together, pitching the insect's body forward at a steep angle. Mangled, she skittered off my arm awkwardly as I watched, my vestigial Jain sensibilities slightly horrifi ed. Finally she reached the precipice, where she somehow took flight and vanished. Excerpted from The Fever: How Malaria Has Ruled Humankind for 500,000 Years by Sonia Shah All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.