Review by New York Times Review
A memoir by Russell Brand. You know, the Russell Brand. THREE men are at the gates of heaven. St. Peter asks them what they did on Earth. The first is a doctor who was married 30 years, earned $1 million a year, but gave half to the free clinic he started. The second is a lawyer who was married 20 years, adopted three children and turned down a job at a big firm to devote his life to pro bono work. They are both let in. St. Peter asks the third man what he did on Earth. "Not much," he says. "I never made more than $7,500 a year. I've been married three times, had five children with five different women, and I'm an alcoholic and a drug addict." And St. Peter says, "What have I seen you in?" Russell Brand, the English comedian and actor, has taken the States by squall with memorable turns in the film "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" and as the unknown but indelible host of the 2008 MTV Video Music Awards. His unflinching 2007 memoir, "My Booky Wook," a runaway-and-not-hide best seller in Britain, has now been slightly updated and released in the United States in an attempt to capitalize on what has been a bloody good start. We have a name for that on this side of the Atlantic: Brand-building. A child's garden of vices, "My Booky Wook" is also a relentless ride with a comic mind clearly at the wheel. That means you get what really happened, as well as material passed off as what really happened. Brand's style is stream of consciousness. Or firth of consciousness. Herein lies the problem. In the repackaging of the book, this 21st-century Fagin has footnoted and explained some local references to de-cockneyfy his work. Some. It's as if his editor said, "I need 100 footnotes by Saturday." Imagine if he had taken the whole weekend to annotate. It is a rough crossing. Brand, who says "American" with the same intimation the party out of power says "this administration," takes to his assignment with the fervor of Pete Best's publicist. If he has a joke, you get a footnote. Otherwise, you're on your own. Among those people, places and things left unasterisked: Peter Sutcliffe, Dot Cotton, Del Boy, Bagpuss, David Walliams, Roy Keane and Rod Hull. I Wikipedia'd "Dot Cotton" and my computer shrugged and said, "Ask Russell Brand." Unlike his immediate predecessors, Ricky Gervais and Eddie Izzard, who debarked on these shores talented but humble, Brand does not make himself accessible to a new audience. He makes us try to catch him. He may very well be funnier or have a longer career, but do we want to work so hard to figure that out? This chronicle of all his notorious, though mostly unseen, moments onstage and on British TV seems at times more like a closing argument at a competency hearing than a memoir. Brand withholds nothing. He drinks. He smokes. He scores. He dope-fiends. And he regrets nothing except those incidents of depravity he may have forgotten. The only thing edited out is remorse. If "rollicking" means "wildly uneven," then his story is indeed rollicking. And that's the most infuriating thing of all. The bloke can write. He rhapsodizes about heroin better than anyone since Jim Carroll. With the flick of his enviable pen, he can summarize childhood thus: "My very first utterance in life was not a single word, but a sentence. It was, 'Don't do that.'" Sadly, when he's got time and space to kill, he'd rather be naughty. He'd rather gratuitously toss off a mention of sex with a vacuum cleaner than stare down the blank page for more of the vivid insight he wields in moments like this: "She wouldn't have known I was a virgin until the bungling encounter commenced (when it would've become startlingly obvious, as I adopted the demeanor of a man struggling to build a cuckoo clock in oven gloves)." Brand spends the last 50 pages clearing the path for redemption, as he finally assails his full buffet of addictions. But in tone, his account of rehab is no different from the way he recounts yet another enabler-financed television project. He does some fancy footwork with the 12 steps. He's not keen on the concept of anonymity, and I'd be willing to bet (if I still bet) he had his manager make his amends for him. There is an English-size Channel between recovery and a killer bit on recovery. Seven pages from closure, Brand shows us this entry in his rehab diary: "Watched 'Malcolm X' - great story but overlong and indulgent filmmaking." Pot paging kettle, anyone? Russell Brand has a compelling story, but it is a story that compels the reader to wish for the more he is clearly capable of. If he stays clean, who knows? He does. And he tells us: "I'll write another book one day about how it feels to become famous . . . but to the people who know me I've been famous for ages." Somewhere, Del Boy and Bagpuss are nodding. Bill Scheft is a writer for "Late Show With David Letterman." His new novel, "Everything Hurts," will be published next week.
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [October 27, 2009]
Review by Library Journal Review
"How could I get back the feeling I'd had in front of that audience?" Brand wonders about acting on page 93. Yes, you read that right-PAGE 93. It takes him THAT LONG to get around to this question, this sudden revelation, this epiphany that every other actor seems to have about page five. It might as well be page 903, because any spark of interest has been killed off long, long before. Brand goes on to describe how he "got on with" learning whatever craft he thinks he does, which translates to an additional 259 pages of doing drugs, failing, and what my catechism referred to as "premarital sexual congress." While Brand earns a few points for honesty, a big vocabulary, and general cheekiness, this is too dreary a recitation of various addiction treatments of a self-indulgent assworm. "It's difficult to be honest," he writes, "because in cold print it seems serious and egotistical" (note: another name for this condition is "Sting"). And while I'm a happily almost-married man, the dormant alpha male in me bridles at the thought of this taco head with Katy Perry in the same way it bristled at John Mayer with Jessica Simpson. Rated: X for eXcrement.-Douglas Lord, "Books for Dudes," Booksmack! 9/2/10 (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.