Review by New York Times Review
THERE'S some evidence that middle-aged heavy metal rock stars lead quiet, blameless lives, doing nothing more satanic than working on their golf and riding A.T.V.'s. But things are very different for Judas Coyne, the protagonist of Joe Hill's first novel. Coyne, once the guitarist and presiding genius behind a band called Jude's Hammer, is a collector of macabre artifacts, including a trepanned skull, a snuff film and Aleister Crowley's childhood chessboard (not all that macabre this last one, I think). So when he has the chance to buy a haunted suit from an online auction site, how can he resist? As it turns out, the suit belonged, and in a sense still does, to one Craddock McDermott, a Vietnam vet turned dowser and mesmerist, and the stepfather of one of Coyne's ex-girlfriends who committed suicide a few years back in ambiguous and bloody circumstances after Coyne ditched her. Coyne's acquisition of the suit unleashes a fine sampling of supernatural horror: visual and auditory hallucinations, induced suicide, phantom dogs, phone calls from the dead, a spirit invoked via a Ouija board and a door drawn on the floor in blood, leading to another dimension. Since the ghost in the suit seems to be untroubled by the rules of time and space, hitting the road seems unlikely to provide much of a solution, but that's what Coyne and his current girlfriend, Georgia, do. They drive a classic Mustang and Craddock pursues them in a cool old phantom Chevy pickup, which is probably going to look great in the movie version. Those of us stuck with the novel have to make do with some strictly meat-and-potatoes prose: shoulders twitch in reflexive surprise; glances are thrown out of windows; upper lips draw back in sneers; eyes glitter like water at the bottom of a well. The description of characters is worse, and some of it sounds like casting notes: Coyne's assistant, Danny, has "high, arched, Jack Nicholson eyebrows"; someone's voice has always reminded Jude "of the comic Steven Wright"; another character bears "a passing resemblance to Charlton Heston." This really doesn't count as novel writing at all, does it? As the book journeys on, we discover that the root and cause of the horror is plain, nasty and all too human: incest and child abuse. Some might think this was overseasoning the bloody mary, but Hill is untroubled by the possibility that more might be less. In a scene as ludicrous as it is unpleasant the ghost climbs into the mouth of Coyne's dying father, like "a wad of Saran Wrap sucked into the tube of a vacuum cleaner." Actually, paternal relationships are pretty vexed throughout the novel; the father once deliberately smashed Coyne's hand with a basement door, quite a blow to a guitarist. Maybe the ghost is performing an act of revenge on the father. Maybe. By this time all pretense at narrative logic or coherence has been abandoned, and Georgia's repeated, italicized, cries of "Why?" are likely to be echoed by the reader. Still, if this is the kind of thing you like, then you're probably going to like this a lot. Whether the book will achieve any sort of pop-horror critical mass is hard to say, but Hill seems to know his audience. The publicity material tells us the movie rights are sold and foreign rights have been sold in "17 countries and counting." However, the publicity declines to tell us another fact, that Joe Hill is the son of Stephen King. I don't know the significance of that omission but I do know that the book contains the line "If hell was anything, it was talk radio - and family." In a better book you'd be inclined to read something into that. Geoff Nicholson's most recent book is "Sex Collectors."
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [October 27, 2009]
Review by Booklist Review
This riveting debut novel is so hip and so frightening that there are sure to be scaredy copycats next year. Aging rock god Jude Coyne is enjoying his semi-retirement as a recluse on his farm with his beloved dogs; his latest groupie-cum-girlfriend, Georgia; and a creepy hobby, collecting objets des macabres. Jude's latest addition to his ghoulish collection is a ghost. The specter resides in an old-fashioned Sunday suit, and, once released from the titular heart-shaped box, begins a mission of revenge. Swinging a curved razor, the black-eyed spirit hypnotizes its victims. Jude's assistant, Danny, hangs himself. Then Georgia sticks a gun in her mouth. Even Jude is not immune to the phantom's murderous lullabies and finds himself in the front seat of his cream-puff Mustang, inhaling carbon monoxide. Hill's tone is gleefully morbid, and his plot plunges and flies like a roller coaster trying to dump all of its shrieking passengers. Both an original effort and an honorable homage to the author's father, horrormeister Stephen King (Hill's real surname is King, too), Heart-Shaped Box heralds the arrival of a horribly good new talent.--Mediatore Stover, Kaite Copyright 2008 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Stoker-winner Hill features a particularly merciless ghost in his powerful first novel. Middle-aged rock star Judas Coyne collects morbid curios for fun, so doesn't think twice about buying a suit advertised at an online auction site as haunted by its dead owner's ghost. Only after it arrives does Judas discover that the suit belonged to Craddock McDermott, the stepfather of one of Coyne's discarded groupies, and that the old man's ghost is a malignant spirit determined to kill Judas in revenge for his stepdaughter's suicide. Judas isn't quite the cad or Craddock the avenging angel this scenario makes them at first, but their true motivations reveal themselves only gradually in a fast-paced plot that crackles with expertly planted surprises and revelations. Hill (20th Century Ghosts) gives his characters believably complex emotional lives that help to anchor the supernatural in psychological reality and prove that (as one character observes) "horror was rooted in sympathy." His subtle and skillful treatment of horrors that could easily have exploded over the top and out of control helps make this a truly memorable debut. (Feb.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Rocker Judas Coyne collects creepy stuff like a hangman's noose but when he buys a ghost off the Internet, he's in real trouble. This wraith is the stepfather of a girl Judas loved and left to suicide. Movie rights have already vanished. (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Adult/High School-Hill, two-time winner of the Bram Stoker Award for his short fiction, delivers a terrifyingly contemporary twist to the traditional ghost story with his first novel. Aging rock star Judas Coyne is a collector of bizarre and macabre artifacts: a used hangman's noose, a snuff film, and rare books on witchcraft. When he purchases a suit billed in an online auction as the haunted clothes of a recently deceased man, Coyne finds more than he bargained for. Everywhere he looks he sees the twisted spirit of an old and evil man following him and dangling a deadly razor on a chain. He learns that the suit belonged to Craddock McDermott, the stepfather of a former lover who committed suicide shortly after Coyne tossed her out of his life. McDermott, a professional hypnotist prior to his death, swore to destroy Coyne's rock-star life of self-indulgence to avenge her death. The behind-the-scenes look at stardom alongside the frightening pyrotechnics of McDermott's ghost will draw in teens who really enjoy a good scare. But like all good ghost stories, Hill also crafts a deftly plotted mystery as McDermott's true motivations and powers unfold. The depth of character hidden in the dark shadows of both men lifts what could otherwise be a formula supernatural thriller to an impressive debut.-Matthew L. Moffett, Pohick Regional Library, Burke, VA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A rock star buys a ghost who chases him from New York to Florida, blood spurting all the way. Jude Coyne, after a career in the darker reaches of the rock-music world, lives in upstate New York with Georgia, the latest in a succession of young pierced admirers he calls by the states of their birth. Georgia's predecessor, Florida, is at the heart of the troubles that arrive when Coyne answers an ad offering a ghost, something special to add to his collection of creepy items that includes a Mexican snuff film. The ghost inhabits a garish suit of clothes that arrives in a heart-shaped box, and the situation is a set-up. Knowing Coyne's taste for the weird, Florida's sister has inveigled him into buying the soul of her and Florida's stupendously evil stepfather, Craddock, a stinker who learned a lot of very bad magic as a soldier in Vietnam. The motive is the apparent suicide of Florida, who Coyne sent home after one too many bouts of depression. Craddock's ghost immediately gets into Coyne's head, urging him to murder Georgia and then commit suicide. Coyne resists, but the bad vibes are too much for his gay personal assistant, who flees the farm and hangs himself. Craddock persists in his attack on Coyne, using a ghostly truck as his assault vehicle. Lesser rock stars would have capitulated early on, but Georgia turns out to be full of spunk, and Coyne's German Shepherds are fierce protectors who the ghost greatly fears. To get rid of Craddock, Coyne figures he will have to go to Florida to find out just what did happen to make that ghost such an abusive spirit. Much will be made of the kinship of Hill and his superstar father, Stephen King, but Hill can stand on his own two feet. He's got horror down pat, and his debut is hair-raising fun. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.