Review by Booklist Review
This fairy tale resolves predictably enough, with the traditional sign-off (They all lived happily ever after ) and a splashy depiction of a royal marriage. Here's the twist: the wedding is actually the story's opener, occurring before any clue about the couple's identity or about why the nuptials are attended by bunnies, a dragon, a flying pig, two giants, an enormous tomato, and a pair of dancing lemons. Patience, dear reader; each subsequent spread portrays the action a beat before its predecessor, flowing backward to supply the needed context and reveal the tale's true beginnings--a reversal of convention that extends to the surprising placement of the a title page at the end of the book. LaRochelle's text is all the funnier for its spare, deadpan statements of effect and cause, each taking maximum advantage of the page turns, and Egielski's artwork exaggerates the zaniness of the reversed narrative by placing it within a mock-stately context, including decorative borders and graceful scrolls containing the hand-lettered text. As fun as it is handsome, this offering will be a hit at storytimes, where it will pair nicely with the wild chain reaction in Remy Charlip's Fortunately (1964) . Present this as inspiration for young storytellers, who may discover that writing a tale in reverse frees their ideas to move in unexpected directions. --Jennifer Mattson Copyright 2007 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
This reverse fairy tale begins with a wedding, a regal cast of fantasy characters and a parchment-colored banner with the requisite words "And they all lived happily ever after." Readers inevitably wonder how this happy ending came to be. Never fear: LaRochelle (The Best Pet of All) and Egielski (Jazper) provide a second banner that heralds, "They lived happily ever after because...," leading to a scene of "the soggy knight" holding hands with the lovestruck princess. But how did the knight get soggy? And why are two giants, eleven rabbits and a scaly green dragon at the door? Subsequent "because..." pages reveal, in backwards order, the events that led to "The End." When readers finally arrive at the title page, wordless endpapers show the lonesome princess in her garden. Readers then can rewind from back to front, to discover the machinations of an elfin cupid and his winged blue pig, who set the mischief in motion. LaRochelle keeps the plot simple, the better to trace the inverted order, and leaves the excitement (the dragon's fiery snort, the giant's temper tantrum, etc.) to the intertwining images. Egielski illustrates in buoyant hues of royal blue, scarlet, daffodil yellow and white, framing each spread with a knobby brown vine motif. He alludes to a deck of cards and to Caldecott's The Queen of Hearts with the diamonds and clubs on the royal wardrobes, and he gives timely visual hints to past and future moments in this nicely realized puzzle. Ages 4-8. (Jan.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 3-Turning the standard fairy-tale formula on its head, LaRochelle begins his story at the end. The endpapers depict a princess and a knight waving good-bye to a long line of intriguing characters who are marching away from the castle. The text begins, "And they all lived happily ever after. They lived happily ever after because-" and proceeds backward through a madcap chain of events that includes a skittish dragon, a giant tomato, a pack of ferocious bunnies, and a fortuitous bowl of lemonade. Only on the last page are readers rewarded with the anticipated phrase, "Once upon a time." Egielski's illustrations are a triumph. The flattened, static quality of the characters calls to mind Maurice Sendak's In the Night Kitchen (HarperCollins, 1995), and the warm, muted tones evoke the fairy-tale art of Trina Schart Hyman, but the fanciful details-a blue, winged pig; a pair of runaway lemons-are completely original. The hand-lettered text, enclosed in streaming banners, consists of terse, declarative statements that are lavishly expounded upon by the illustrations. The tension between the simplicity of the narrative and the richness of the artwork allows this tale to transcend its clever gimmickry. Though the book can be appreciated in one reading, and would work well when shared aloud, multiple perusals are necessary to spot all of the details. When youngsters reach the beginning of The End, they will want to start all over again.-Rachael Vilmar, Atlanta Fulton Public Library, GA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
(Primary) Here's a new twist on the fairy tale, as LaRochelle and Egielski tell a story from the end to the beginning, starting with the words ""And they all lived happily ever after."" Egielski's pictures -- complete with giants, a smiling bride and groom, a scaly green dragon, and other icons of the fairy-tale world -- nearly burst out of the elegantly twining vines that frame the pages. Upon closer inspection, other details come into view -- a blue pig with wings, two dancing lemons with legs and arms, bunnies, a sprite, a baker. The beginning of the second sentence tells the reader where all this is going: backwards. ""They lived happily ever after because..."" Ah, now we get it. The book gallops through all the riotous events that led to the royal wedding on the first page. There's the flaming beard of the knight, the crying dragon, one hundred bunny rabbits, and one enormous tomato rolling down the hill. The silliness progresses (or regresses?) all the way to the title page, the copyright page, and then onto the endpapers. Youngsters will read this book over and over, from front to back and back again, drinking in the details all along the way. Copryight 2007 of The Horn Book, Inc. All rights reserved. (c) Copyright 2010. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Not to be confused with a recent Unfortunate Event of the same title, this funny, playful folklorish episode may be told front to back, but it's actually laid out in reverse. LaRochelle opens with the old "Happily Ever After," then retraces a sequence of linked, thoroughly daffy events that leads up to it. Egielski supplies plenty of visual juice, beginning with a packed crowd scene featuring a knight, a princess, a dragon, a huge tomato, two giants, a pair of smiling lemons, a swarm of rabbits, a blue flying pig and more. Then he proceeds to show how each of these elements figures in as the story winds backward, with many "because" explanations ("An enormous tomato was rolling down the hill because . . . "), past the copyright page and title spread to a peaceful pre-title prelude. The reversed narrative, hilarious turn-of-the-page plot twists and bright, comical, precisely drawn art add up to an uncommonly clever outing that invites reading--in either direction. (Picture book. 6-8) Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
