Review by Booklist Review
The Oates universe is tense and overcast when it isn't under assault by grimly devastating storms. An expert in the causes and effects of obsession, desolation, and annihilation, Oates has crafted hundreds of mesmerizing short stories of acute social and psychological insights, sinister sexuality, and stark violence. Nine new, hard-hitting stories of fractured families, death, and longing kick off this supreme retrospective collection. High Lonesome tracks the absurd and tragic circumstances that instigate a suicide and a revenge killing. In Spider Boy, a son helplessly reveals the shocking truth about his father. In \lquote The Cousins, a woman writes to the thorny author of a controversial Holocaust memoir, certain that they're related. Oates even offers a chilling biotech cautionary tale. Two-dozen standout stories from the past four decades follow these new works, beginning with a harrowing tale of a hurricane, Upon the Sweeping Flood, and moving on to quintessential Oatesean tales of cataclysms seeded in the human heart. Oates' daring oeuvre, immense in size, depth, and spirit, will stand as a pillar in American literature, and this collection of stories that Oates feels are her best is as significant as it is breathtaking. --Donna Seaman Copyright 2006 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
This hefty collection, featuring 10 new pieces along with stories culled from four decades, further establishes the prolific and wide-ranging Oates as a gifted chronicler of American culture. The theme of girls and women preyed upon by violent men appears repeatedly, as in the much-anthologized "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" (1970) but also in lesser-known pieces like "Small Avalanches" (1974), which turns the tables, as a 13-year-old girl, nimble and laughing, evades a middle-aged, panting lech on a deserted path. Several stories feature characters whose mental instabilities lead to violence, as in "Last Days" (1984), in which a brilliant, manic college student with a Messiah complex assassinates a rabbi, then turns the gun on himself. Though Oates's world is often ugly, she also displays a more fanciful (if still creepy) impulse; the recent piece "Fat Man My Love" finds actress "Pippi" (indubitably Tippi Hedren) puzzling over the director (an unnamed Hitchcock) who both created and ruined her career. While the lurid events of some stories have a ripped-from-the-headlines feel, Oates is never merely sensational, tracking hidden motives and emotions with a sharp eye for psychological detail-everything conveyed in lucid, rhythmic prose. However much is made of her prodigious output, it's the consistent quality of the work that lifts Oates into the literary pantheon. (Apr.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Like a successful rock band putting together a best-of compilation CD, Oates (The Falls) has compiled stories from her 40 years of writing along with nine new ones. Although from her afterword it is not clear that she considers these her best, they do provide a sample of her work. Seven of the nine new opening stories focus on families in disarray, e.g., the title work tells of the unsolved murder of the narrator's stepbrother, while "The Fish Factory" examines the extremes to which a teenage girl goes to escape her overprotective mother. The volume then flashes back to the 1960s and works forward by decade. The first decade's stories exhibit an inventiveness exemplified by "Four Summers," in which a girl's experience over four summers makes her satisfied with her life decisions. The 1970s stories are highlighted by "The Lady with the Pet Dog" and "The Tryst," which reveal two different extramarital affairs that go bad, and the mysterious "Night Side" about investigating s?ances. The 1980s stories, such as "My Warszawa: 1980" about a writer's experience at a conference in Communist Poland, reflect Oates's ability to create ironic and often eerie episodes. The 1990s stories are the best in the volume. "The Hair" deals with social hierarchies as two couples become friendly, while stories like "Life After High School," about an outcast student, and "Mark of Satan," which follows a Christian missionary's visit to an ex-con, explore themes of alienation and loneliness in dramatic fashion. For Oates fans and readers who want an overview of her ability to create a snapshot in time, this is an excellent volume. Recommended for larger collections.-Joshua Cohen, Mid-Hudson Lib. Syst., Poughkeepsie, NY (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
An imposing collection of 35 stories. Of the 25 stories reprinted here from earlier volumes, the best include a searching treatment of religious experience ("In the Region of Ice"); rich homages to literary masters ("The Dead," "The Lady with the Pet Dog"); a haunting exploration of spiritualism ("Night-Side"); a nicely detailed racetrack story ("Raven's Wing"); and one of the author's creepiest depictions of adolescent sexual confusion ("Heat"). The principle of selection explained in a brief Afterword doesn't account for the omission of some of Oates's very best-- notably, one of her finest deployments of symbolism, in "First Views of the Enemy" (since reworked in several later stories) and the compact Dreiserian masterpiece "Waiting." The new stories vary in quality largely according to the degree to which they're overplotted. "*BD* 11 1 87," for example, painstakingly builds a wrenching characterization of a lonely, orphaned high-school senior inexplicably discouraged from realizing his considerable potential--then throws it away as the story spins into banal near-futuristic fantasy. The title story, about an aging farmer destroyed when he's caught in a vice squad sting, almost collapses when emphasis shifts to revenge taken on his behalf--but Oates gives it conviction through understatement and deft pacing. "The Lost Brother," which describes a middleaged woman's determined, doomed search for her estranged sibling, works brilliantly, as everything left unsaid eloquently ensnares the reader. Other stories deal all too predictably and heatedly with shattered families ("Spider-Boy," "Soft-Core," "The Cousins") and sexual violence ("The Fish Factory," "The Gathering Squall," "In Hot May"). Then there's "Fat Man My Love," an ironic remembrance of an adipose film-industry giant by one of his "Ice Blondes," which does to the memory of Alfred Hitchcock what Oates did to Marilyn Monroe in the wretched novel Blonde. Who's next? Shirley Temple? Dame Edith Evans? Lassie? Enough, already. Otherwise, a longstanding literary need somewhat successfully addressed with this collection. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.