Review by Booklist Review
Smith, a Londoner by birth, was a mere 24 years old when her first novel, White Teeth (2000), burst upon the literary scene. A surprising triumph of mature writing, it was reviewed widely and glowingly and climbed high onto the best-sellers lists. The good news is that her eagerly anticipated second novel is no sophomore slump. It is as bracingly intelligent and humorous as her first. On a thematic level, the novel is a meditation on celebrity. On a literal level, it is a rich, often wild, series of events in the peculiar life of a British-Chinese-Jewish man, Alex-Li Tandem, who by profession--and obsession--is a trader in autographs of the rich and famous. Alex's story rests on one abiding central conflict: his need to own an autograph of Kitty Alexander, a retired and reclusive actress big in the 1950s. Alex's relationship with girlfriend Esther is almost incidental--as are all other features of his life--in the face of his years of attempting to pry a signature out of the worldly wise and weary Kitty. His pursuit of this Holy Grail takes him from London, where he lives, to the much-edgier New York City, and what transpires there makes for a highly dramatic, very entertaining romp. --Brad Hooper
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Smith's eagerly awaited second novel begins with a bang, but rapidly loses momentum, slipping from tragicomedy to rather overdetermined farce. The introductory set piece is panoramically sock-o in the best Martin Amis tradition, taking us from Doctor Li-Jin Tandem's outing with his son's friends to see a wrestling match in Albert Hall to his sudden death from a massive stroke. Fifteen years to the week later, Li-Jin's son, Alex, is being pressed by his friends, Adams Jacobs and Joseph Klein, to say Kaddish for his dad. Alex is an autograph trader and obsessive egotist. Over the course of the week, he wrecks his car on an acid trip, goes to New York in quest of the legendary retired actress Kitty Alexander, frees her from her mad manager (who promptly announces her death to the papers, thus inflating the value of her signature) and gets his girlfriend Esther, Adam's sister, angry enough that she suspends their relationship. Smith paints portraits of a very multiculti Judaism: Adam, for instance, is a black Jew, while Alex is a disbelieving Chinese one. Adam's kabbalistic interests are supposed to operate in Smith's text the way Homer's poem operated in Ulysses, giving it a mythic dimension, but the big theme of Jewishness feels tacked on, like a marquee advertising a former attraction. Smith's pen portraits of the shabby, yobbish autograph trading circle are intermittently funny, but her prose is so busy being clever that the laughter never builds. This is disappointing but, even with its faults, the novel points to a literary talent of a high order. (Oct. 8) Forecast: Smith's second novel should sell very well on the strength of her reputation alone, though it may not be the smash hit White Teeth was. Eight-city author tour. (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
This is the story of one man's journey to find meaning in his life. Alex-Li Tandem, a 27-year-old who is half-Chinese and half-Jewish, ekes out an existence as an autograph dealer. Besides trying to find himself, Alex is also trying to get an elusive autograph of his favorite actress, a B-movie star from the 1950s named Kitty Alexander. The story devolves into a mishmash of fantasy and half-truths that are so twisted it is impossible to know where reality begins, let alone ends. Most of the characters are without dimension and simply serve as caricatures of bizarre individuals. Despite the needlessly long path of madcap adventures that morph into dreams or fantasies, this is a tortured tale that will wear out the best-intentioned of listeners. Even the tidbits about the Kabbalah, Zen Buddhism, and an alphabetical pursuit of drinks do not uplift this drivel. Steven Crossley's masterful reading is the only elevating feature. He is able to breathe some life into these lackluster and boring figures in an attempt to instill some animation into a painful listening experience. Smith won the Commonwealth Writers First Book Prize and the Whitbread First Novel Award for her first book, White Teeth. Her fans may want to give this a try just out of loyalty, but they should be warned that they will likely be disappointed. Not recommended.-Gloria Maxwell, Penn Valley Community Coll., Kansas City, MO (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The follow-up to Smith's smashing debut success (White Teeth, 2000, film rights recently sold to Miramax) is an uneasy mix of Sunset Boulevard, J.P. Donleavy's The Ginger Man, and James McCourt's fey romantic comedies about dementedly self-absorbed beautiful people. The arresting, promising prologue describes a day trip to London's Royal Albert Hall to attend a pro wrestling match, undertaken by 12-year-old Alex-li Tandem (son of a Jewish mother and Chinese father) and two young friends-during which Alex-li meets a younger boy passionately devoted to autograph-collecting, and loses his father, a 30ish surgeon, to a heart attack. Alas, it's all downhill thereafter, as Smith zooms ahead to focus on her protagonist at age 27; his frustrated romantic relationship with a young woman (Esther), who's also cardiacally challenged; his search for religious certainty among the arcane minutiae of Jewishness, "Goyishness," and Zen Buddhism; and his career as a collector, "verifier," and marketer (and sometime forger) of celebrity autographs. The real love of Alex-li's insular life is reclusive former screen beauty Kitty Alexander, and the quest for her rare signature takes him to conventions and auctions, misadventures with a host of walk-on weirdos (a trio of rabbis, commenting like a Borscht-Belt Jewish Greek chorus; importunate celeb-hunter Brian Duchamp, and others too numerous-and arbitrarily bizarre-to mention); and a trip to New York City to attend an Autographicana Fair, following which "the most famous whore in the world" assists his discovery of the now-moribund Kitty, living in Norma Desmond-like seclusion, guarded with Cerberus-esque ferocity by her p.r. manager Max Krause. It's even less appetizing than such summary sounds, because all the characters are brash, opinionated cartoons, and the loose texture is repeatedly stretched to accommodate interpolated jokes, faux parables, lists, diagrams, and whatnot. Shrill, labored, and boring. Unless this is actually Smith's first novel, it's a disappointing step backward. Author tour
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.