Review by Booklist Review
A cold winter in the Alaskan bush becomes even colder when a forest ranger loses his job in a politically motivated firing. Then a conservationist is murdered, and the tensions that have been swirling around the question of whether to drill for oil on the preserve erupt into local warfare. Aleutian PI Kate Shugak campaigns to save the fired ranger and, with the help of Alaska State Trooper Jim Chopin, attempts to solve the murder before more violence erupts. This twelfth Kate Shugak mystery is among the series' best, a definite return to form from the disappointing previous entry, The Singing of the Dead [BKL My 1 01]. The pacing is strong throughout, the environmental issues are handled sensitively, the scenery is striking as always, and the mystery's solution comes as a definite surprise. The Shugak series is an obvious read-alike for such celebrated wilderness mysteries as those by Nevada Barr and Sue Henry, but it also pairs well with Marcia Simpson's strong first novel Sound Tracks [BKL Je 1 & 15 01]. --John Rowen
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
This is the 12th in a series (after 2001's The Singing of the Dead) that truly evolves rather than simply revisiting the same setting, although that setting is a doozy: an austere and beautiful Alaskan outback, populated with eccentrics and wild creatures. Kate Shugak could be considered a little of both, having grown up in this hinterland and being fond of her own ways. Kate discovers that park ranger Dan O'Brian is about to lose his job, probably because he is against drilling for oil in the local wildlife preserve. In an effort to garner support for Dan, Kate calls on her late grandmother's dear friends, Ruthe and Dina, who together taught Kate the name of every living thing in the park when she was a child. This longtime couple sits on a big chunk of pristine wilderness and works hard to protect other areas. Meanwhile, Dan has fallen for Christie Turner, the new waitress at the Roadhouse, and state trooper Jim Chopin, a notorious womanizer, is focused on the one woman who won't give him the time of day Kate. She isn't ready for a new relationship, as she is still mourning her dead lover, Jack Morgan, and trying to provide a stable environment for his teenage son, Johnny. When Dina is killed and Ruthe is put on the critical list at the hospital, Kate scrambles to solve the crime while keeping a balance in the rest of her life. Along the way, she finds herself in a brief but torrid encounter with Jim. Rich with details about life in this snowbound culture, the story moves at a steady pace to a classic ending. (June 17) Forecast: A five-city author tour will help build on the momentum of last year's well-received The Singing of the Dead, though generic jacket art doesn't signal that the author transcends the "regional" category. (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
The well-known Alaskan P.I. finds herself in the middle of a volatile situation involving proposed drilling for oil in a wildlife preserve. A ranger there is fired for political reasons, and then an important conservationist is poisoned. Be sure to have this on hand. (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Kate Shugak's 12th adventure (The Singing of the Dead, 2001, etc.) begins with a threat against the Park, the beloved wilderness she shares with Stabenow's other regulars. Chief Ranger Dan O'Brian is being encouraged to retire by an administration that sees Alaska as acres of oilfields covered by so much snow. When Kate mobilizes her network to protect O'Brian, she discovers that not everyone agrees with his environmental policies. Some members of the Native Association badly want more jobs, and miners and big-game hunting guides like John Letourneau would welcome a, well, less tightly regulated business environment. In due course, Kate calls on friends of her grandmother, Dina Willner and Ruthe Bauman, still in old age adventurous souls and outspoken environmentalists who are happy to speak up for Ranger O'Brian. But before they can, Dandy Mike walks into their cabin to find Dina stabbed to death, Ruthe mortally wounded, and Dan O'Brian, bloody and confused, behind the door. Even though Dan refuses to tell all he knows, Trooper Jim Chopin clears him and arrests a homeless veteran clutching the murder weapon and muttering about angels. Then John Letourneau, Dina and Ruthe's neighbor and business rival, types out a confession and shoots himself. Have Kate and Jim, distracted by their explosive mutual attraction, missed something? Stabenow enjoys tantalizing her fans with Jim and Kate's romance, but her pleasure in her beloved creations can be self-indulgent. When she finally gets around to the serious business of murder, it's satisfying but anticlimactic.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
