Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
After lighting the Hanukkah candles, Al Rosen and his son, who are both pale-skinned, stroll around their city neighborhood. It's also Christmas Eve, and when Al learns that the local Black newsstand clerk is working and can't be with his family, Al volunteers to take over--beginning adecades-long tradition of the "Christmas Mitzvah," as he and, later, his family, stand in for Christian neighbors who have jobs that are "easy to dismiss in a world that mistakes wealth for worth." Peppy, inclusive, and richly colored digital art by Agatha portray an oft-frazzled Al juggling the demands of the jobs he's stepped into. As his generosity inspires, people of various faiths soon carry on the Christmas Mitzvah by volunteering on "each other's special days." Gottesfeld succeeds in highlighting a compassionate lesson of community care, and the importance of turning kindheartedness into action. Back matter features an author's note with links to more information on the real Al Rosen, as well as Hanukkah. Ages 4--8. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 2--This inspirational cross-cultural story, based on true events, captures the holiday spirit; however, it may appeal more to adults than children. Al Rosen is a Jewish man who loves Christmas. One Christmas Eve, he offers to take over a newsstand clerk's job to allow the clerk to spend Christmas Eve with his family. This act prompts Al to offer to do people's jobs for Christmas Eve and it inspires others to do the same. On the year Al decides he is too old, many people he has helped come together to celebrate him, inspiring a multicultural lighting of the Chanukah candles. This story has an adult sentiment. Other than mentions of his children and grandchildren, it centers on Al. The inspirational content will appeal to adults and rides the line of cloying. That said, the message is a worthy one and the writing is clear, concise, and accessible. The cartoon-style illustrations are humorous and appealing, depicting a multicultural cast that includes people of all races, as well as those wearing turbans and hijabs. Agatha uses a vibrant color palette that draws the eye and creates effective pacing, with a mix of full-bleed single pages and spreads, as well as some spot art. VERDICT Schools and libraries looking for an inspirational story that goes down easily and will likely appeal to parents and grandparents will find this fits the bill. Buy where budgets allow.--Amy Lilien-Harper, Wilton Lib., CT
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Gottesfeld (Twenty-One Steps, rev. 3/21) tells the story of real-life mensch Al Rosen, a "Jewish man who loved Christmas." Rosen became locally famous in Milwaukee, beginning in 1969 and for several decades, by covering celebrants' Christmastime work shifts. Per the straightforward text, Al ran a newsstand, pumped gas, sorted mail, shined shoes, and much more. Cheerful digital illustrations show him gamely going about the tasks; a colorful bartending scene, complete with rainbow-hued spillage, reads, "Some jobs he did better than others." Near the end of his life, and at the end of the book, everyone whom Al had helped -- "all the folks easy to dismiss in a world that mistakes wealth for worth" -- gratifyingly comes together to celebrate Hanukkah with his family. Elissa Gershowitz November/December 2021 p.20(c) Copyright 2021. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A Jewish man and his family perform good deeds for non-Jews on Christmas Eve. Al Rosen, who celebrates Hanukkah, loves Christmas, a holiday of "peace on earth and goodwill to humanity." He does good deeds, or mitzvahs, for neighbors, at first taking the Christmas Eve shift at the local newsstand so the regular clerk can spend the night with his family. Later he goes on the radio to volunteer to work for Christians on Christmas Eve. His labors take him from grocery store to mail room to parking lot to barn. For many years he performs these many different jobs by himself and sometimes with his son and grandchildren, becoming a "local legend." People of other faiths, Christian and Muslim, then return the favor on the Jewish High Holidays for Al and his family. But "years piled up like drifts in a blizzard," and one year Al is too old--but in a grand finale, all join together to light the Hanukkah menorah: It's a veritable "throng of God's children." An author's note references the real Al Rosen of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, who performed these acts starting in 1969. The brightly colored, busy illustrations fill the pages with a nicely diverse collection of active and energetic folk working and smiling as a community. A heartwarming slice of neighborly love, caring, and sharing. (author's note) (Picture book. 6-9) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
