Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
In this English-language debut by German author Böge, comprehensive prose in the third-person perspective closely follows the journey of one canary from the Harz Mountains; he works in a silver mine and sings at night until being sold to a bird dealer, who takes him on a journey across the Atlantic Ocean with 188 other canaries: "The light looks gray under the canvas cover. They can hear the gravel under the dealer's boots." Mixed-media illustrations by Klever are richly colored and have a fantastical, folkloric feel, following the gently expressive, bright yellow bird. While younger readers may find the dense paragraphs less appealing, older children partial to illustrated animal-centered fiction will find much to appreciate. Back matter includes detailed notes on the history of canaries. Ages 6--10. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 1--3--Lush illustrations and text full of sensory descriptions make this narrative nonfiction story of how canaries came to America a real pleasure to read and share with young readers. The story follows the journey of one canary from its mountain home in the Harz Mountains in Austria, where it accompanies silver miners during the day and sings its lovely tunes to a family at night. A bird dealer comes to take the canary, along with 188 others (189 referring to the number of small bird cages that will fit in layers of a large backpack) on a long journey on foot over the mountains, then to a train, then a ship headed across the Atlantic, and finally to a pet store in New York City, where the bird meets its new human family. Back matter includes a brief history of the birds, originally from the Canary Islands off the coast of Africa, a picture of the many varieties of the bird, as well as a map showing the route of the journey from Europe to North America. Human characters default to white; the vast majority of the illustrations depict the birds and imaginative drawings of the canary, the surroundings, and even the birdsong. VERDICT A delightful story of a little-known piece of history, with the added bonus of a fun math connection for students studying multiplication.--Sue Morgan, Hillsborough City Sch. Dist., Hillsborough, CA
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
"This is the story of a long journey, but I'll keep it as short as I can because it has such a lovely ending." This fascinating, very beautiful picture book describes the journey, in the nineteenth century, of one canary, part of a group of 189, transported by a bird trader via foot, train, and steamship from the silver mines of the Harz Mountains in Germany to New York, where it is purchased as a pet. The storytelling style uses the present tense to pull the reader directly into a faraway time and place. Boge's narration is full of sensory details ("With every step, the rack sways left, then right. The cages rub against each other, and the thin wooden bars creak quietly") that are particularly appropriate for a story about a bird prized for its voice. Klever's mixed-media illustrations, with a muted color palette, have the flat perspective of folk art. The canary is the brightest object on most pages, and Klever expresses the richness of its song with imagery of the things whose sounds influence it, including trees, wind, rain, waves, trains, and other animals. An extensive, highly illustrated afterword includes a history of canaries and their use in mining and as pets. Maeve Visser Knoth November/December 2021 p.65(c) Copyright 2021. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The titular 189 canaries bring their unique songs from the mountains of Germany to bustling New York harbor. High in the Harz Mountains of Germany, canaries are bred for use in the silver mines. Their ability to detect high levels of carbon monoxide alerts miners to escape the tunnels to reach fresh air. These canaries also learn to sing beautiful melodies unlike any other in the world. This story focuses on the journey of one canary who is placed in a tiny cage, strapped onto a large rack with 188 other tiny cages, each containing a single canary. Transported by foot, cart, train, and ocean liner, the feathered protagonist finally winds up in New York, where he is purchased by a little girl. Originally published in German, this historical picture book was created with the advice and support of the Harz Roller Museum in Germany. The third-person narration has a descriptive simplicity that ties together the canary's observations with a zoomed-out view of the voyage. The linear storytelling is full of graceful imagery, often reflected in the illustrations. Using a folk art--meets-hipster style, the illustrations lean into a rich, warm color palette. Backmatter presents a short history of canaries in captivity, information on their ability to learn songs from one another, and the ways canaries were used and transported by humans in the 19th century. While the uniqueness of Harz Roller canaries is celebrated, quality of life for birds bred for captivity is never addressed. All human characters have pale skin. A quiet story that savors the historical details of a bird's trans-Atlantic journey. (Picture book. 6-9) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
