Review by Booklist Review
Magic has always been part of life in Belling Bright, where residents keep jars of it for uses both practical and frivolous. Though everyone uses magic to one degree or another, Wendell Anders is renowned for his extraordinary abilities with it, and everyone assumes that his daughter, Rose, will be just as proficient. She's about to turn 12, which means she can finally participate in the annual capturing of magic and prove to everyone that she is just as remarkable as they hope. After all, as her father insists, people only attract the magic they deserve. When things don't turn out as she hoped, though, Rose's father fumes, and she's despondent. What does it say about her worth in a magical town if she can barely capture a jar of the stuff? Haydu's (Eventown, 2019) story is a stunner. Its magic system is inventive and imaginative, and Rose and her world are drawn with care and compassion. But beyond the magic, there's an important thread of emotional, and eventually physical, abuse in the Anders family, and while the implications are subtle at first, by the story's end, there's no denying their impact on the close-knit family and community at large. It's a carefully crafted message of hope and the sometimes-painful beauty in forging an identity all your own.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
With taut underlying tension and a sympathetically flawed protagonist, Haydu's (Ever Cursed) middle grade novel literalizes magic's effects on a family and community. Rose Alice Anders has looked forward to this upcoming New Year's Eve, her 12th birthday, for as long as she can remember. In Belling Bright, the anniversary means she's old enough to join her family at TooBlue Lake, catching magic on New Year's Day. To Rose's father, the town's most celebrated magic-catcher, it means that she--his "Little Luck"--will finally follow in his footsteps. But despite encouragement from her less magically inclined brother, who takes after their mother, Rose catches only one jar of magic--angering their volatile father, leading her to question her destiny, and resulting in social fallout. Using insightful flashbacks to reveal Rose's conflicted feelings about her dad and her desire to fulfill his dream, Haydu deftly, and with startling clarity, portrays the presence and devastating effect of abuse on a family. The sweet protectiveness of older brother Lyle, Rose's gradual awareness and acceptance of herself, and the hope that families and people can heal offer further thoughtfully rendered touches. Ages 8--12. Agent: Victoria Marini, Irene Goodman Literary. (Feb.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4--7--Expectation runs high for 12-year-old Rose Anders, whose father, Wendell, is the most successful magic-catcher in Belling Bright. His jars of trapped magic fill every closet. Rose, described as having blue eyes and brown curly hair, awaits her first magic-catching day with rising dread. Her friends Maddy, with blonde braids, and Ginger, whose appearance is not described, seem to be tiring of Rose's incessant proclamations of her heir apparent status, while at home her father's dodgy advice becomes overbearing, even as her brother Lyle and passive mother try to still its contentious waves. Magic-catching day does not go as planned for Rose, and she suffers an embarrassing letdown. Meeting a family who is "Not Meant for Magic" and dealing with her father's ominous mood swings, Rose confronts the effect magic has on her family and community. Haydu's work of magical realism evokes fraught emotions boiling just below the surface of Rose's "perfect" life. Her first-person narration begins with a confident arrogance that slowly dissipates along with her father's public geniality. The quirky joys a jar of magic can provide, like pink hair, rainbows, and bad weather, delicately balance against Rose's descent from popularity into a near pariah. Rose's visceral pain and her hard-earned agency will be deeply felt. While age appropriate, the story does contain possible triggers for domestic abuse survivors. VERDICT Readers who enjoy everyday magic, friendship stories, and family drama will be enchanted by this magic jar of a book.--Caitlin Augusta, Stratford Lib. Assoc., CT
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Magic is a physical object in Haydu's (Hand-Me-Down Magic, rev. 7/20) latest middle-grade novel, and the residents of the town of Belling Bright turn out to capture it in jars every New Year's Day. On New Year's Eve, Rose Alice Anders turns twelve, the age when residents are allowed to capture magic, and her famous father, known for capturing more magic than anyone else, is certain that she has a special connection to it, just as he does. But when Rose ends New Year's Day having filled just a single jar -- and that only because of her older brother's help -- she has to deal with her father's severe disappointment, which she's spent most of her life deflecting. As Rose watches her friends make themselves beautiful and popular with their new supplies of magic, she starts to reevaluate magic's importance as well as her relationship with her father. Readers who pick up on the emotional abuse from the book's early pages ("when Dad's the one in charge, you don't say no"; "he doesn't love when we do anything he doesn't do") may find Rose's gradual realization a tad slow, but the novel will appeal to those who enjoy a quiet, emotion-driven fantasy. Sarah Rettger January/February 2021 p.104(c) Copyright 2021. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Rose Alice Anders learns magic can't fix everything, despite what her father has always told her. The daughter of the most magical man in town, Rose is destined to follow in his footsteps. When she turns 12, she can finally join the rest of her community and participate in the annual capturing of magic on New Year's Day. But when the day arrives, she only manages to catch one measly jar of magic. Her father is furious, and to make things worse, her relationship with her best friend is falling apart. Rose feels like an utter failure until she learns that some people are "Not Meant for Magic," an option she never knew existed. As she begins to question who she's truly meant to be, she also starts to acknowledge the painful truth about her father. The worldbuilding and magic system are enchanting and expertly crafted, but the core of this gorgeously written story isn't magic at all: It's abuse--and it's absolutely heartbreaking and completely realistic. While the abuse is never downplayed, this heavy subject is approached through Rose's first-person narration in a way that is fitting for its intended audience. The characters are richly developed and emotionally complex; a beautiful, tender sibling relationship stands out, showing mutual understanding and emotional support in ways both large and small. The ending is empowering and plausibly hopeful. Characters are White by default. Affecting and unforgettable. (author's note, resources) (Fiction. 9-13) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
