Review by Booklist Review
Miéville (The Last Days of New Paris, 2016), better known for his speculative fiction (he won both the British Fantasy Award and the Arthur C. Clarke Award twice), draws on his academic credentials in social anthropology and Marxism in this well-researched account of the Russian Revolution on its centennial anniversary. A summative pre-history starts the book, which then narrows to a month-by-month examination of the events leading to the rise of Vladimir Lenin in October 1917, the most pivotal month in modern Russia. The elevated language indicates the book's seriousness; its historiographical approach establishes its credence. Miéville challenges past popular claims, offers divergent thought, and questions accuracy. Fans of the writer will recognize the literary quality of his prose: Trench-drenched soldiers the colour of ripped-up earth taking what hours of respite they could, drinking tea from tin mugs. Lenin famously wrote, It is more pleasant and useful to go through the experience of the revolution than to write about it. Readers will be satisfied that October gives them the literary equivalent of bearing witness to world history.--Tempone, Frank Copyright 2017 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Miéville (The Last Days of New Paris) marks the centenary of Russia's dual 1917 revolutions with this vivid and insightful study of the journey from the February Revolution, which "dispensed breakneck with a half-millennium of autocratic rule," to Lenin's October triumph. Situating these eight turbulent months within the city of St. Petersburg, the czarist capital and the birthplace of the uprisings, Miéville writes that the story is "above all the story of its streets." He leads readers through these streets and the complicated relationships between competing, and often violently opposed, groups of radicals-old and new Bolsheviks, Mensheviks, Socialist Revolutionaries, and others-from workers' strikes through Lenin's proclamation of socialism and Russian withdrawal from WWI. Miéville is fully aware of the horrors that followed this massive achievement but convincingly argues that the Russian Revolution's "degradation was not a given"; its formative moments carried immense potential for every kind of human liberation, which could so easily have become the dominant force of the new order. As an acclaimed storyteller with a doctorate in political philosophy and a commitment to leftist activism, Miéville is an ideal guide through this complex historical moment, giving agency to obscure and better-known participants alike, and depicting the revolution as both a tragically lost opportunity and an ongoing source of inspiration. (May) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Although Tsar Nicholas II and mystic Grigori -Rasputin have come to symbolize the Russian Revolution, Miéville (Perdido Street Station) recounts other pivotal figures (and events) in the months leading up to October 1917. The prerevolution months involved key players such as chief of staff Mikhail Alekseyev and Marxist activist Leon Trotsky negotiating first with the Tsar and then with each other. To complicate matters, the minority Mensheviks and Bolsheviks majority could not agree on what a provisional government should look like. Mensheviks believed the liberal bourgeoisie should take power; Bolsheviks argued for the proletariat to become ultimate leaders. Initially, the two parties were able to work together as Bolshevik leaders suggested the bourgeoisie should take power until the proletariat was ready for their own revolution. Although several players are involved, Miéville includes a beneficial glossary of names and a thorough overview of events, successfully tying together their motives and actions. VERDICT This riveting account offers a different aspect of the revolution that changed the course of Russian history. Recommended for all readers.-Sonnet Ireland, St. Tammany Parish P.L., Mandeville, LA © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The award-winning fiction writer revisits the exciting, messy story of an explosive Russia on the brink of civil war.London-born novelist and political theorist Miville (Three Moments of an Explosion: Stories, 2015, etc.) takes on the roiling events of the Russian Revolution on the 100th anniversary of the Bolshevik insurrection. From the beginning of 1917, events occurred at a dizzying pace and involved a rich cast of characters, which the author delineates at the end of the book in a "Glossary of Personal Names." Miville tells the story in a frank, mannerist fashion. Of course, since readers know the outcome ("purges, gulags, starvation, mass murder"), there is a sense of dark foreboding throughout. The author questions whether it was inevitable that Vladimir Lenin and his cohort would shift increasingly to the left and embrace violent insurrection. No: events were constantly shifting and up in the air, and Miville presents the action with his novelist's eye. Looking to the "prehistory of 1917," the author chronicles the cataclysmic changes in Russia in the late 19th century especially, including emancipation of the serfs in 1861 by Alexander II, who was assassinated by "People's Will" radicals in 1881. "The man of the future in Russia," noted populist writer Alexander Herzen, "is the peasant." The Marxists believed that autocratic Russia was not yet ripe for socialism. Thus, the events that unfolded over the next two decades, as the working class gained confidence and size, were inchoate until brought into sharper focus by external crises such as the Russo-Japanese War, anti-Jewish pogroms, the institution of a "consultative parliament," the Duma, by Czar Nicolas II, and the deeply unpopular mobilization for war against Germany in 1914. It was a "fraught and protean political culture," as the author writes, juggling the many activist protagonists such as Leon Trotsky, who was working to incorporate the incendiary ideals of Lenin. An intriguing march to revolution, told here with clarity and insight. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
