Review by Choice Review
In this captivating study, Martin (a freelance writer) transports the reader to the 1850s inside smoky Pfaff's saloon--the meeting place of the US's first Bohemians--located in the basement of 674 Broadway in New York City. Run by Charles Pfaff, a cheerful German immigrant, the subterranean vault became the stomping grounds of Henry Clapp Jr., editor of the Saturday Press, who wished to re-create in New York the Bohemian scene he had experienced while living in Paris. Pfaff's offered the ideal venue. In its heyday--the years leading up to the Civil War--the saloon was frequented by artists, writers, actors, and comics, including a handful of women, who became known as Pfaff's Bohemians. Among those who patronized the saloon most nights was Walt Whitman, whose time at Pfaff's, Martin argues, was critical in the evolution of the poet's verse. Whitman's immersion in the Bohemian scene provided him with the freedom to experiment with his poetry and his sexuality. Thanks to meticulous research, Martin was able to re-create the Bohemian scene, and Whitman's place in it, in vivid detail. This book is a lively and entertaining read for students of American literature, history, and culture. Summing Up: Essential. All readers. --Denise D. Knight, SUNY College at Cortland
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* America's first cultural bohemian, Henry Clapp Jr., was an erstwhile puritan radical (abolitionist, pacifist, teetotaler) who'd lived in the original, Parisian bohemia. Returning to New York a new man he'd learned to drink he fixed on a basement biergarten, Pfaff's at Broadway and Bleecker, as the place to host an avant-garde roundtable. Soon, young writers and artists flocked, but Clapp lacked a Lancelot to put forward as the best advanced artist in America. Enter Walt Whitman, without whom Pfaff's saloon and Clapp's circle would be much more obscure than they are. Clapp knew what he was looking for: not a brilliant, heavy-drinking, irreverent, flamboyant brat but someone accustomed to honing his work and biding the time it took to be appreciated, even if that someone was no drinker, wit, or iconoclast, distinctive but hardly showy, and middle-aged. Martin constructs a group biography of the circle at Pfaff's by alternating chapters about Whitman and about Clapp and the most successful of the youngsters, including prolific writer and prodigious drunkard Fitz-James O'Brien, celebrity druggie Fitz Hugh Ludlow, stand-up comedian Artemus Ward (the first of the kind, Martin says), and liberated woman and theatrical sensation Adah Isaacs Menken. This is popular history the way it should be, well-researched and authoritative yet demotic in idiom and unpretentious in presentation, a darn good read.--Olson, Ray Copyright 2014 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Martin (Genius of Place) offers an engaging history of a literary underground-a bohemian group headed by Henry Clapp Jr.-that actually gathered underground, sitting around a long table in a vaulted room at Pfaff's saloon in New York City. Though Walt Whitman is the best-known of the group, readers may find themselves drawn to his lesser-known comrades: Fitz Hugh Ludlow, author of The Hashish Eater; actress Ada Clare; Adah Isaac Menken, who achieved considerable fame on stage, tied naked to a horse in the opera Mazeppa; and Charlie Brown (aka Artemus Ward), who was considered "America's first stand-up comedian." Martin's writing rises to the occasion; readers will long to have heard Ward's act, to have seen a production of Mazeppa, or to have read selections from Ludlow's book and Clare's columns in the Saturday Press. The main focus of the book is Whitman-his participation in circle, his efforts to publish Leaves of Grass, his ministering to wounded soldiers, and his infatuation with Peter Doyle. Highlights include Ludlow's travels with artist Albert Bierstadt and a brief appearance by Mark Twain. Despite the author's evident passion and considerable research, the narrative suffers from occasional choppiness and repetition. But it's still a worthwhile read despite these minor flaws and introduces armchair literary historians to a dazzling cast of eccentrics. 16 pages of b&w photos. Agent: Don Fehr, Trident Media Group. (Sept.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Martin (Genius of Place: The Life of Frederick Law Olmsted) focuses on the little-discussed Bohemian scene based out of the Manhattan bar Pfaff's in the late 1850s and early 1860s. We read about the group's ringleader, journalist Henry Clapp Jr., and his bacchanalian acolytes, including the writers Fitz-James O'Brien and Fitz Hugh Ludlow, actress and poet Adah Isaacs Menken, columnist and feminist Ada Clare, actor Edwin Booth (brother of Abraham Lincoln's assassin, John Wilkes Booth), comedian Artemus Ward, and, most important, poet Walt Whitman. Martin successfully demonstrates the group's impact on the still-obscure Whitman, especially Clapp's through his influential but short-lived literary newspaper the Saturday Press. Clapp's Bohemian scene flourished from 1858 until the start of the Civil War, which dispersed its members across the country. Martin traces their paths afterward, including Ward's friendship with a young Mark Twain out West. VERDICT This accessible, briskly paced book brings attention to a rich but sorely overlooked scene, shades of which are still present in today's American artistic and intellectual circles. Fans of American literature and counterculture will find plenty to enjoy.-Brian Flota, James Madison Univ., Harrisonburg, VA (c) Copyright 2014. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Walt Whitman (1819-1892) is only the best known of Martin's (Genius of Place: The Life of Frederick Law Olmsted, 2011, etc.) gallery of the 19th-century bohemians who haunted Pfaff's Saloon in New York City. The leader of this boisterous set was Henry Clapp (1814-1875), an irreverent moral relativist who thrilled in playing off his coterie of writers and artists for the best put-downs and bons mots. Clapp's attitude sprang from his experiences in Paris' Latin Quarter, where he met the true bohemians who formed the basis of La Vie de Bohme. They sat in Caf Momus discussing, rather than producing, their art and drinking strong coffee and stronger alcohol. Mostly, they had no money, no prospects, multiple romances and lots of talk. Ultimately, these circumstances brought Clapp back to the saloon on the corner of Broadway and Bleeker Street to interact with the fascinating crowd he met there night after night. Though Whitman was often there, he was not always with Clapp's crowd. He also spent time with new friends in the larger room, where one's sexuality was not a matter of discussion. Many of the figures in Martin's entertaining cultural history failed miserably, and many died young. Some like actor Edwin Booth (brother to John Wilkes) and humor writer Artemus Ward, left their marks, while others faded away. As they spread across America and the Atlantic, they met writers as diverse as Mark Twain and Charles Dickens. Clapp vigorously promoted Whitman's Leaves of Grass and gave Twain his first national break in the Saturday Press. Martin truly opens up the characters of these creative, sensitive men, examining their lives before the Civil War and the ways in which they reacted to it. The author's solid research into the connections of these curiously varied men and women makes this a wonderful story of one of the world's odd little cultural cliques. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
