What W.H. Auden can do for you

I've never heard Smith's voice, but I imagine it as slow, kindly and avuncular, the type given to the owl in animated children's movies, with something like the steadying influence of Mr. J.L.B. Matekoni (from Smith's "No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency" series). When Smith assures us that reading W.H. Auden can change our lives, we believe him. What is the Auden-driven life? A thoughtful one, clearly, as Smith describes it. He provides a bare-bones biography of Auden and outlines his major themes, but the book comes alive when Smith connects his own moral and intellectual growth to his appreciation of the poet. Auden's musings on choice and responsibility, for instance, meant much to Smith during his doctoral work on criminal liability under duress: The more he thought about it, "the more I realized that the territory of real responsibility - those things for which we had to shoulder complete blame - was small indeed. Auden's insights into this issue were useful, as indeed he was useful on so many matters." Anyone interested in the intellectual underpinnings of Smith's warm and humane novels should read this book, which would also make a good introduction to Auden for serious younger readers.

If you're a fan of McCall Smith's,you know that he's a fan of W. H. Auden. His two series set in Edinburgh Scotland Street and the Isabel Dalhousie novels have characters who frequently quote Auden. In this installment of the Writers on Writers series, McCall Smith, with a wink to Alain de Botton's How Proust Can Change Your Life (1998), sets out to speak directly about what Auden has meant to him and how readers who have never read the poet can be enriched by his work. McCall Smith is marvelous in describing scenes from his own life that were made radiant or understandable by Auden's poetry. He is less successful, except in a general poetry can change your life way, in relating Auden to new readers. This book wanders quite a bit, and it certainly won't generate Auden converts, but it will help both Auden and McCall Smith fans understand the themes and values of both.--Fletcher, Connie Copyright 2010 Booklist

A beloved author waxes poetic on an unlikely muse: the poet W.H. Auden. Poetry probably isn't the first word to come to mind when thinking about McCall Smith's work. A lawyer by training (and the author of Botswana's only published legal text), he is best known for his wildly popular commercial mystery series, The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency. However, as he reveals in this slim, category-defying volume, Auden has had a profound impact not only on McCall Smith's work, but his life as a whole. His succinct ode to the celebrated British poet is not a memoir, though he includes a few moments from his own life--e.g., how he discovered Auden as a student in Belfast and how he began to understand him reading Bucolics on the Hebrides off the coast of Scotland. Nor is the book a biography, though there are some charming details about Auden's life as well--one particular story about his atrocious housekeeping skills is impossible to forget. McCall Smith is adamant that the book should not be read as criticism, as Auden's body of work has been analyzed in detail by countless literary scholars, though he spends much of the text taking readers (rather haphazardly) through some of the major themes of Auden's poetry. If anything, though, the book could best be called an argument for Auden, a defense of his work, and a simple case for people to continue to pay attention to this particular writer. As McCall Smith writes early on, "I believe that reading the work of W.H. Auden may make a difference to one's life." A lovely yet overstretched article or essay topic; there's earnest enthusiasm aplenty but not enough else to support a full book.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.