Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Noted forensic expert Ramsland (The Forensic Science of C.S.I.) disappoints with this plodding history of the evolution of forensic investigation. Tracing the earliest roots of what has become an invaluable component of criminal investigations and legal proceedings, Ramsland begins in ancient Greece, with Heraclitus' and Paramenides' philosophies of change and permanence as the governing forces of the world. Moving her way through the Industrial Revolution and Charles Dickens's apparent coining of the word "detective," Ramsland laboriously documents case after case as investigators refine methods of fingerprinting, poison detection, ballistics and identification of potential repeat offenders. Ramsland concludes with a brief exploration of the future of forensic investigation, from sophisticated DNA analysis to the global role of forensics in the age of terrorism. Too little time is spent on some of history's most notorious cases (such as Lizzie Borden and Leopold and Loeb), with Ramsland instead offering numerous accounts of husbands poisoning their rich wives. Despite a subject so ripe for historical and sociological examination, Ramsland waters down her topic until the cases run together. Without any variation in her chronological narration, Ramsland will lose even the most dedicated of readers and C.S.I. fans. (Sept. 4) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A thumbnail history of forensic science, ranging from ancient China to the O.J. Simpson trial. Ramsland (Forensic Psychology/DeSales Univ.; Inside the Minds of Serial Killers: Why They Kill, 2006, etc.) is certainly the grande dame in this field, with more than 30 titles to her credit, most of them crime nonfiction focusing on forensics. Here she provides a quick history of how forensic science and criminal investigation have evolved throughout history. Since much of this territory has been extensively picked over in many previous titles, the most interesting elements come near the beginning, when the material is less familiar. For example, Ramsland gives an intriguing thumbnail sketch of Sung Tz'u, a 13th-century Chinese lawyer who wrote The Washing Away of Unjust Imputations, one of the oldest works on forensic technique. From there the narrative marches steadily through the ages, spending most of its time in the 19th and 20th centuries. Ramsland takes readers through each crucial development in forensics from ballistics and fingerprints to the supposed Holy Grail of DNA, first perfected in England in the 1980s. Here and there some fascinating characters pop out, like Fran‡ois Vidocq, the colorful reformed French thief who in 1812 created the Sûret, the world's first undercover detective organization. But for the most part Ramsland's prose, though concise and clear, keeps readers at a distance. The author makes no real attempt to offer a thesis or draw any general conclusions; she simply accumulates facts in chronological order. An enervating litany of research, dully presented. Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
