Not a box

Antoinette Portis

Book - 2006

To an imaginative bunny, a box is not always just a box.

Saved in:

Children's Room Show me where

jE/Portis
1 / 2 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
Children's Room jE/Portis Checked In
Children's Room jE/Portis Due Apr 7, 2024
Subjects
Genres
Picture books
Published
New York, NY : HarperCollins 2006.
Language
English
Main Author
Antoinette Portis (-)
Physical Description
unpaged : ill
ISBN
9780061123238
9780061123221
Contents unavailable.
Review by New York Times Review

DO children still know how to play? The flourishing market for picture books that promote playing as worthwhile (and, yes, fun) suggests that many of us aren't confident that they do, or that parents do enough to encourage them. Still, the impulse to "make believe" is strong at a very young age. Imagination animates toys, turns pots into drums, gives nature a role. As Dylan Thomas remembered in "Fern Hill": "I was prince of the apple towns/ ... I lordly had the trees and leaves/Trail with daisies and barley/Down the rivers of the windfall light." Children's books have long celebrated that kind of creative play. A.A. Milne's "Winnie-the-Pooh" still satisfies children who dream of toys coming alive. From the same era, the children in Arthur Ransome's 1930 tale "Swallows and Amazons" turn an island camping trip into a spirited free-for-all between pirates and a shipshape crew. A generation later, John Burningham used delicious irony in "Come Away From the Water, Shirley" to present a small girl's lushly painted fantasy life in counterpoint with her sketchily drawn parents, who sit in beach chairs issuing the warnings that inspire her wild scenarios. While Shirley's parents haven't an inkling of her thrilling make-believe, the parents in "Swallows and Amazons" sympathize with their children's plans for adult-free sailing and island life. Daddy's cabled permission is classic: "Better drowned than duffers if not duffers won't drown." Such books depict the kind of free-wheeling play we fondly remember. They're also exciting stories with memorable characters. A lot of new picture books seem to reflect the concern that creative play is becoming a thing of the past. Some merely portray imaginative activities, as if children might not think to invent them. Antoinette Portis's "Not a Box" (an "Honor Book" for the 2007 Geisel Award, given by the American Library Association for "the most distinguished book for beginning readers") is one of these. Portis enlivens it, though, with a developing argument between her rabbit character and an annoying offstage voice: "Why are you sitting in a box? ... What are you doing on top of that box?" "It's not a box!" retorts the rabbit, in words emblazoned on a full page of primary red. And, later, "It's NOT NOT NOT NOT a box!" The square book, seemingly made of brown cardboard, itself looks amusingly like a box, from its "11.5 oz." net weight to its admonitory "this side up." Also, those offstage questions are set on box-brown pages, which, like the rabbit's increasingly exasperated replies, appear on the left. Meanwhile, in the illustrations on the right, sober black-and-white reality alternates with the rabbit's fantasies, which are boldly drawn in brilliant red against jubilant yellow; the actual rabbit and box are evoked by just a few broad, black, lightly feathered lines. The unquenchable hero perches atop "Rabbit Peak," hoses a burning building, blasts off into space. The graphics are handsome, the debate authentically childlike. Still, there's just the one idea: imagination transforms. And the conclusion lacks punch. Asked, finally, "Well, what is it then?" the best the rabbit can come up with is: "It's my Not-a-Box!" IN "The Birthday Box," Leslie Patricelli offers a similar riff on the same idea. Once it's unwrapped, the box of the title turns out to contain a doggy playmate, Oscar; the box itself becomes a plane, a ship, a sled and, at last (in good picture book tradition), the bed where the two characters curl up for a nap. Patricelli's several board books feature the same round-faced, diaper-clad tot, who looks barely a year old - an age when children are less likely to engage in dramatic play than to have fun simply putting something into a box and taking it out again, like Eeyore. Certainly no preschooler will be capable of snipping holes in sturdy cardboard, as shown. But babies will relate to the bright colors, clear drawings and toddler-proven activities: ripping off gift wrap, climbing onto a box and sharing stories. "I am very lucky," the tot tells Oscar as they snuggle down in their cardboard bed. "Today is my birthday, and I got a box!" Both of these books are well worth a few readings, and they'll remind parents what play can be. Still, they don't offer the kind of story that draws children back, over and over, to relive events, visit beloved characters and pore over details - the kind that sparks spontaneous, creative and independent play. Joanna Rudge Long, a former editor at Kirkus Reviews, writes and lectures about children's books.

Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [October 27, 2009]
Review by Booklist Review

Wrapped in basic, grocery-bag-brown paper, this streamlined book visualizes a child's imagined games. Why are you sitting in a box? reads the opening page, opposite an image of a small rabbit, drawn in the simplest, unshaded lines, who appears next to a square. It's not a box, reads the text, presumably in the rabbit's defiant voice, on the next page, and equally simple red lines overlay the black-lined rabbit and box to show a speeding roadster. In the following spreads, the questioner (a clueless adult?) continues to ask about the rabbit's plans, while the little voice answers with the book's protest of a title. This owes a large debt to Crockett Johnson's Harold and the Purple Crayon (1955). And as in Johnson's classic, the spare, streamlined design and the visual messages about imagination's power will easily draw young children, who will recognize their own flights of fantasy. --Gillian Engberg Copyright 2006 Booklist

From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

Sometimes the best toys are improvised, according to this celebration of the humble cardboard box. Packaged in a plain brown jacket that resembles a paper bag (another item with vast potential), this minimalist book features a rabbit-child, simply drawn in a heavy black line. In the first spread, designed in neutral black, white and tan, the rabbit's head peeks out of a rectangle. An offstage voice asks, "Why are you sitting in a box?" When the page turns, the rabbit answers, "It's not a box." A touch of color comes into the image. The empty white background is tinted pale yellow, and a thick red line traces a racecar over the basic black box shape, revealing what the rabbit imagines. By the time the skeptical voice inquires, "Now you're wearing a box?," readers know to expect a playful transformation in the next spread. "This is not a box," replies the rabbit, as a red robot suit is superimposed over the initial drawing. The teasing questions challenge the young rabbit, who demonstrates that a box can serve as a pirate-ship crow's nest, a hot-air balloon basket and a rocket. Readers won't abandon their battery-charged plastic toys, but they might join in a game of reimagining everyday objects. Most profitably, Portis reminds everyone (especially her adult audience) that creativity doesn't require complicated set-ups. Ages 6 mos.-6 yrs. (Jan.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review

PreS-Gr 1-In bold, unornamented line drawings of a rabbit and a box, the author-illustrator offers a paean to the time-honored imaginative play of young children who can turn a cardboard box into whatever their creativity can conjure. Through a series of paired questions and answers, the rabbit is queried about why he is sitting in, standing on, spraying, or wearing a box. Each time, he insists, "It's not a box!" and the opposite page reveals the many things a small child's pretending can make of one: a race car, a mountain, a burning building, a robot. One important caveat: the younger end of the intended audience is both literal and concrete in their approach to this material. The box itself, drawn as a one-dimensional rectangle, will be perceived by preschoolers to be flat and not readily understood as three-dimensional. Furthermore, those children are likely to interpret the "box's" transformation to be "magic," while five- and six-year-olds are able to make the cognitive conversion from flat rectangle to three-dimensional box and to understand that the transformation has been made by the rabbit's own imagination. Both audiences will enjoy the participatory aspect of identifying each of the rabbit's new inventions. Knowledgeable adults will bring along a large box to aid in understanding and to encourage even more ideas and play.-Kate McClelland, Perrot Memorial Library, Old Greenwich, CT (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review

(Preschool) A cardboard box might not make the Toys ""R"" Us top sellers' list, but it's the only plaything an imaginative bunny needs to stay entertained. An offstage narrator asks philistine questions such as ""why are you sitting in a box?"" and ""what are you doing on top of that box?"" -- impelling the bunny to point out repeatedly that ""it's not a box."" It is, as the strikingly simple cartoon illustrations show, a boat or a race car or a mountain. To the unobservant eye, the box is a mere white rectangle, heavily outlined in black; but Portis embellishes it with images done in red outline to show, for instance, the burning building it becomes when the bunny plays firefighter. Even the book's dust jacket is boxlike, with its grocery bag color and texture and ""This Side Up"" directive, flanked by two red arrows, on the back. Increasingly exasperated (""It's NOT NOT NOT NOT a box!""), the bunny finally finds a sensible way to escape the narrator's badgering -- turn the ""Not-a-Box"" into a rocket ship and zoom away. (c) Copyright 2010. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. All rights reserved.

(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review

Dedicated "to children everywhere sitting in cardboard boxes," this elemental debut depicts a bunny with big, looping ears demonstrating to a rather thick, unseen questioner ("Are you still standing around in that box?") that what might look like an ordinary carton is actually a race car, a mountain, a burning building, a spaceship or anything else the imagination might dream up. Portis pairs each question and increasingly emphatic response with a playscape of Crockett Johnson-style simplicity, digitally drawn with single red and black lines against generally pale color fields. Appropriately bound in brown paper, this makes its profound point more directly than such like-themed tales as Marisabina Russo's Big Brown Box (2000) or Dana Kessimakis Smith's Brave Spaceboy (2005). (Picture book. 5-7) Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.